Callout 1 of 3
Tiled slopes in Whittington, cracked or worn out
The Victoria County History's 1913 account of the parish describes St Philip and St James, the church "erected in 1842" of coursed rubble with sandstone dressings, and says "The walls are plastered internally and have opentimber tiled roofs". For houses it notes that "In the village on the main road are some 18th-century brick houses", and that Crookbarrow manor-house is "a late 17th-century brick building". A roof of that age may not be the first the house has carried, and the survey works out what is there by reading the battens, the underlay and the fixings, never by guessing from the road. The ridge, hips and valleys are read in the same visit, since a slope is not judged in isolation. Underlay gets a look wherever tiles come off: it should lie flat with its laps intact, and torn underlay is renewed with the covering.
On sound battens, a handful of cracked or slipped tiles is a repair, done with matching tiles and fresh clips where the old ones have rusted. The harder call is the whole covering, and lifespans depend on the material and on who is counting. For concrete tiles, Marley says "around 60 years" while HomeBuilding gives 40-50 years. HomeBuilding puts Welsh slate at "100+ years". Read those as ranges, not promises: a covering younger than its range can still fail early where the battens beneath have rotted.
If the survey shows the covering is finished, the Planning Portal sets a two-part test for England: nothing normally needs applying for where "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" is affected and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected". Both parts of that test must be met. A heavier covering is judged on its own: a new material that "increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more" needs approval, and AD A, the structural approved document, calls a rise of more than 15% "a significant change in roof loading".
For Whittington addresses, building control is South Worcestershire Building Control, a partnership between Worcester City, Malvern Hills and Wychavon councils, with a registered building control approver as the private route. When a whole slope is stripped, we photograph the bare battens so you can see whether they will be reused or renewed. Our roof replacement page sets out how a full re-cover runs, from the first batten to the last ridge tile.
Repair or re-cover?
Should a cracked tile be replaced or the whole slope re-covered?
Sound battens with a handful of cracked tiles call for a repair. When the battens have rotted, or many tiles are loose, the survey photographs the evidence and the written price covers whichever job the roof needs.















