Callout 1 of 3
Stone tiles and slates on the Staunton slopes
Callout one is the slope. For its monuments 4 to 11 in this parish the Royal Commission recorded, in a 1934 entry, roofs of "stone or modern slates". Two coverings are named there, for eight buildings and a single date, so it is a hint about the past and nothing about the roof over your head. Yours could be stone, slate, tile or a mixture, and the survey establishes which before any repair is planned.
Local sandstone tilestones roof Herefordshire's traditional stone buildings, the county's building stone atlas explains, and it names the St Maughans sandstones as the chief source. SPAB describes stone and Welsh slate roofs in the region as "predominantly double-lapped", so every course sits partly over the one below and partly over the one beneath that. A slipped stone tile is mended by lifting the courses around it, never by forcing a tile into the gap.
Matching is the hard part. SPAB observes that many of these roofs now carry another stone, slate or imitation stone slates, and that supply claims "should always be checked with the quarries". We check before suggesting a swap away from stone. A stone tile's age says little, so we weigh each one by its condition and its fixings, and you see each one in the photographs.
Slate has firmer figures. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate "100+ years", and SPAB says a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years". Cupa, a slate maker, advises against slate hooks below 25 degrees of pitch, so the pitch is measured on site and nails or hooks are chosen to suit. Where a slate roof is sound but tired at the eaves, replacing the worst courses can be enough.
Tile coverings have their own figures. Marley lists minimum pitches by product, with its plain concrete tile at 35 degrees and its clay Canterbury tile at 40, and each of those is a product, not a regional style. For clay tiles, Marley reports a BRE minimum life expectancy of 60 years, which applies to clay only. For concrete tiles Marley says around 60 years and HomeBuilding says 40 to 50, so we name both and read the condition of each tile on site.
Our slate roofing page covers slate work in depth. Staunton on Arrow lies in England, so the Planning Portal's tests govern a re-cover: less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof. Staying under both limits means an application is normally unnecessary, while a bigger scheme goes to building control.
Stone or slate?
Can a stone-tiled roof be repaired instead of re-covered?
Yes, so long as the tiles around the fault are sound. We raise the next courses up, re-lay the loose tiles in the same overlap and replace broken ones with a match. A slope that has failed across its whole face is another matter, and the photographs show which case you have.
A stone tile's age tells us little, so each one is judged on its own condition.















