Callout 1 of 3
Stone slates, modern slates and the Madley roof
First on the drawing is the slope. The Royal Commission's 1931 inventory of Herefordshire covers Madley parish, and for monuments 4 to 24 it records stone slates or modern slates as the coverings of the roofs. Those are two coverings with different habits, and a roof patched over the years can carry both. The first job at the ladder is to tell them apart. A stone slate is thick and uneven, and a modern slate is thin and regular. We lift a few courses at a sound spot and photograph what is there, so you can see how your roof was made.
The county's stone atlas points to sandstones of the St Maughans Formation, worked around the Golden Valley, as the chief supplier of the county's stone roof tiles, and it records that many permissions to quarry that stone are still active near the county's western edge. The same atlas says that Downton Castle Sandstone "has been used historically both as a freestone and as a tilestone". SPAB's note on slate and stone roofing describes the double-lapped method, in which the slates overlap in two layers, so a crack in one is covered by the course beneath. The same note mentions "some purple types in Herefordshire".
Sorting is where a repair is won or lost. A slate that has slipped may have lost its fixing, and a sound one can go back. Reusing sound stock keeps the look of the roof and keeps the cost to what the survey finds. Where new stock is needed, SPAB's rule is that a claim of scarce supply goes back to the quarries to be tested, and that is the first call we make. On lifespan, SPAB says a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years", and HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate "100+ years" and reclaimed Welsh slate "50-80 years". For stone tiles we judge pitch and remaining life from the roof in front of us.
A full re-cover brings the weight test into play. The Planning Portal sets the line at a covering that adds 15 per cent or more to the roof, and a covering past that line needs approval, with the rafters checked first. Our slate roofing page covers natural slate and stone in more depth.
Two coverings, two ways of reading them
- Stone slate
- Thick and uneven; sorted and refixed where sound
- Modern slate
- Thin and regular; replaced slate for slate
- Double lapping
- Two layers of overlap, so one crack is covered
- Matching
- Supply asked of the quarry before any change
- Weight
- A heavier covering needs a structural check
A sound slate is sorted and refixed, and a failed one is replaced with the nearest match we can find.















