Callout 1 of 3
Flagstone roofs on Longtown's older cottages
Callout one is the slope. The Herefordshire building stone atlas, a Strategic Stone Study published in 2012 and edited by the British Geological Survey, states that "Older cottages in Longtown are still roofed with flagstones". A flagstone roof is built of sandstone slabs split from the rock, laid course on course from the eaves upwards. According to the atlas, the county's tilestones come chiefly from the St Maughans Formation, and there are numerous active permissions in the extreme west of Herefordshire, in the Golden Valley area, so the supply is not a thing of the past.
The Royal Commission's inventory of 1931 is more specific about this parish. At the Parish Church of St. Clodock, which stands on the left bank of the Monnow, it found ordinary slates and stone slates together on the roofs. For the other buildings it numbered 8 to 45, it wrote that the walls are stone rubble and the roofs are "stone or modern slates". A Longtown roof may therefore be flagstone throughout, or stone with slate worked in, and a repair has to begin from what the roof truly is.
SPAB regrets that on many roofs in this region the original stone has been "changed to different stones or even to slates or fake stone slates". When we meet a mixed roof, the report says so, with a photograph of each material. On a flagstone slope we look for slabs that have slipped out of line, cracked across, or lost their bedding at the verge, and we check the ridge and the eaves course, where weather leaves the roof. Seen from beneath, a stone roof shows its faults as daylight at the gaps and dark stains on the rafters, and we record both. Nothing is lifted before a picture has been taken.
Changing a covering is a structural matter as well as a visual one. On the Planning Portal's figure, a new covering that is 15 per cent or more heavier needs approval, while Approved Document A speaks of "more than 15%". Where slate has been used in a patch, HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate "100+ years" and reclaimed Welsh slate "50-80 years", and SPAB calls the life of a well-slated roof "likely to be more than 100 years". Those are typical figures, not promises, and sound slate is worth keeping. For one slab or a patch of verge, see roof repairs.
A flagstone that has slipped
Does one slipped flagstone mean a new roof?
No. The slab is lifted, the bedding and its neighbours are checked, and it is relaid or matched from stock. The photographs show whether the courses around it have held. A new roof is discussed when a slope has failed as a whole, and the photographs show it.















