Callout 1 of 3
Slate slopes and the brick beneath them
The Victoria County History's 2010 account of Huntley parish describes the outbuildings of Edmund Probyn's late-1850s farmstead at Woodend, designed by J. & J. Girdwood, as "of orange-red brick with slate roofs and form an E which opens to the south". That covers a single group of buildings and tells us nothing about any other roof in the parish. It does show that slate on brick belongs to the local picture, and the slope is where we begin, read from the ground first and course by course.
A slate roof fails in small steps. Nails corrode or the slate itself splits along its layers, one slate slips a few centimetres and leaves a gap, and the batten beneath starts to take water. We count the slipped and cracked slates from the ground and again from the roof, and the photographs show each one where it sits. A handful of failures is a repair: the slate is drawn out and a replacement slid in and fixed. Pitch matters to slate, so it goes on the survey sheet every time. Cupa, a slate supplier, says hook fixings should be avoided below 25º, and says BS 5534 puts the floor at 20 degrees for natural slate when exposure is moderate, the slate is 500mm long and the overlap is 115mm. A slate laid shallower than its maker allows will let water back up under the lap, and no amount of patching fixes that. Where the pitch is marginal, the report names the covering that suits the slope.
Lifespan depends on origin. HomeBuilding's table lists Welsh slate at 100+ years, Spanish natural slate at 75 to 100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate at 50 to 80 years, while SPAB calls a well-slated roof likely to last more than a century. These are typical figures and not promises, and they explain why sound slates on a worn roof may be worth stripping, sorting and fixing again, with matched slates filling the gaps.
Matching raises a supply question. SPAB advises that "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries", so the survey includes a call to a quarry before anyone is told a slate cannot be had. If the whole slope has gone, the choice lies between that careful re-covering and a new roof, with the report naming whichever the evidence supports. Our slate roofing page covers natural slate in more depth.
Slate lifespans as published
- Welsh slate
- HomeBuilding: 100+ years
- Spanish natural slate
- HomeBuilding: 75 to 100 years
- Reclaimed Welsh slate
- HomeBuilding: 50 to 80 years
- A well-slated roof
- SPAB: likely to be more than 100 years
Sound slates on a tired roof can be lifted, sorted and laid again.















