In brief
Yes, where the work touches what makes the building special, and a new opening in a roof slope is likely to. In England, section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires consent. In Wales, sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 do the same. Class C permitted development still applies, with consent added on top.
Two separate permissions
Planning and listed building consent are different things. Classes B and C of permitted development stay available to a listed house, in England and in Wales, since neither class carves listed buildings out. Listed building consent is then needed in addition, for works that touch the character of the building. Both laws ask the same thing: what the work does to the building's special interest, whatever the size of the window.
In England, section 7 of the 1990 Act requires consent for works "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest, unless the works are authorised". In Wales, section 88(1) of the 2023 Act says a person must not carry out such works unless they are authorised under section 89, which provides for listed building consent. Section 88 has been in force since 4 November 2024.
A roof window can therefore satisfy Class C and still need consent. The two work differently: Class C is met by keeping to its conditions, and consent is obtained by asking the council, which decides. Neither stands in for the other.
Why a roof slope is sensitive
A new window changes the look of the roof and can mean cutting into old timber, which is why the council is asked before anything is ordered. When we survey, we note:
- what covers the roof, and whether that covering is original
- the rafters and battens at the position of the window
- which slope is seen from the road or the lane
- any earlier alterations to the roof, such as patched areas or a past opening
- whether the ceiling and lining inside are old plaster or later boarding
On an older border house the roof may be slate or local stone tiles, and a window there means cutting and lapping a covering that is not easy to replace. The cut slates or tiles are set aside and reused where they are sound, so the finished slope keeps its own material.
Where a replacement is needed, a matching one is traced before the roof is opened. We would sooner put a window where the covering is sound than over a weak patch. Our listed and heritage roofing service covers the wider work on older roofs.
England and Wales compared
| Point | England | Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Consent law | LBCA 1990, section 7 | Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023, sections 88 and 89 |
| Class C | Kept; a conservation area does not remove it | Kept; but a roof light is outside it on article 1(5) land |
| Who decides | The council | The council, or the National Park Authority inside the Park |
| Energy figure | 1.4 or WER Band B | 1.4 or WER Band B |
A conservation area, a National Park or a National Landscape adds a further layer in Wales, because the permitted right to a roof light is lost there. In England, ask your council whether an Article 4 direction applies. Inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, ask the National Park Authority, since it and not the county council handles planning there.
The planning conditions, which apply to a listed house just as to any other, are quoted in our roof window planning guide. For a full re-roof on an older house, see re-roofing a listed building in Herefordshire. Listing does not alter the energy figure for the glazing, so the window still has to meet it.
What we do before any order
The slope and the room are photographed, the opening is measured, and you are given drawings and photographs to take to the council. Whether consent is needed for your house is the council's decision, so ask before any order for the window is placed.
When the survey is done you get a written total that names the window, its flashing and the finish inside. If consent is refused or comes with conditions, the figure is revised before work begins, not after, and nothing is ordered until the decision is known.
Some owners want the window on the slope that the road cannot see, and that is worth discussing with the council early. A back slope or a smaller window can each change how the application is received, though only the council can say how. Photographs of the slope from the road help, and we take them from the same spot a planning officer would.
Because a listed house can have its own history of repairs, we keep the photographs and measurements together in one set that you can hand to the council or file with the house papers. The skylight side of the work is on the Velux and skylights page.
