In brief
It can, but how much turns on two choices, the underlay and the insulation, and the answer is not the same for every roof. Marley's advice for an unheated loft under high-resistance underlay is an unbroken gap at the eaves: 25mm on pitches up to 15 degrees, 10mm on anything steeper. Underlay that lets air through, above a ceiling sealed against draughts from below, can make do with far less, if its product certificate allows. Insulating at the rafters changes the picture again.
Why the underlay settles the question
Underlay is the sheet stretched over the rafters, below the battens, which deals with anything that gets past the covering. Two broad families are fitted. The high-resistance sort, called HR, does not let vapour through. The low-resistance sort, LR, lets air and vapour pass.
The difference matters because a cold roof space, meaning the loft above insulation laid along the ceiling, receives damp air from the rooms below. If that air has nowhere to go, it turns to water on cold timber. Over the years that wets rafters, and wet rafters rot. Slate and tile roofs alike are affected, which is why the question is asked on every pitched job and not only on old houses.
So the first question before a roll is ordered is which underlay, and the second is where the insulation will sit. They go into the price together, because one decision constrains the other. A roll that demands open eaves is no use on a roof whose eaves cannot take a vent, and the reverse can also be true. Marley's published guidance is the reference we work from, and we show you the page the figures come from.
Eaves gaps where HR underlay is fitted
Marley's answer when HR underlay is used is a gap that runs the full eaves line, and its depth depends on pitch:
| Roof pitch | Gap along the eaves |
|---|---|
| 15 degrees or less | 25mm |
| More than 15 degrees | 10mm |
Where the underlay is LR and the ceiling below is sealed, Marley counts the 3mm that normal eaves building leaves anyway as sufficient. The proviso is that the certification the product carries under UKAS third-party schemes is met in full, so the certificate sets the limit, never an assumption.
Those are one manufacturer's figures, so we also read the data sheet for the exact underlay and covering chosen, since a different make can carry different conditions. The gap is formed with eaves vents or a vented fascia strip, put in before the first course goes on. A fully closed eaves detail, such as a tight soffit with no vent, would defeat the purpose. For the covering side of the same decision, see choosing a new roof covering.
What the regulations expect, in England and in Wales
Dealing with condensation is part of what the Building Regulations ask of a roof. The paperwork reads differently from one nation to the other.
- In England, Approved Document C (2013) points to BS 5250:2002 clause 8.4 and BS EN ISO 13788:2002 for condensation. BS 5250 is shown as in force, with a review pending.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government publishes separate approved documents that carry a Wales label, so ask the council's building control which applies to your roof.
On a conservatory, the Planning Portal's English guidance expects a new roof to be safe structurally, energy efficient and properly ventilated.
Whether the work needs approval at all also depends on the address. At an English address the Planning Portal sets two thresholds, under 25 per cent of the building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof. At a Welsh address the Welsh Government begins from the opposite end: in most situations a re-roof needs approval. Where approval is required, the council or a registered building control approver looks at ventilation along with everything else.
When the insulation moves up to the rafters
Foam applied under the rafters makes a warm roof out of a cold one, and the ventilation logic changes with it. The Energy Saving Trust (EST) explains that closed-cell foam cannot pass vapour, which it names as the main drawback, whereas open-cell foam passes more. Spraying foam straight onto the underside partly seals the timber. EST adds that, with open-cell foam, the chance of rot should be much lower.
Lenders are a separate hurdle. RICS said in March 2023 that lenders in some segments had raised concern, with equity release mortgages as one example. Put the question to your lender before you commit. RICS also points owners to their mortgage provider, to confirm the product fits its policy. A one-line email to the lender does that.
Where foam is already in place, taking it out is a job of its own. Choices on warmth are set out in insulation when replacing a roof, and the whole subject sits under roof replacement. We settle ventilation and insulation together, before any figure is written.
