Short answer
What you can see is underlay, the membrane laid on the rafters beneath the tiles or slates, and it is showing because a covering has slipped, cracked or blown off. Underlay is a second line of defence, not a weatherproof surface, so a gap needs closing soon. Photograph it from the ground, do not climb up, and have the missing piece replaced and the underlay and battens beneath it checked.
What the felt is, and why it should stay hidden
On a pitched roof, the tiles or slates you see from the street are the weather covering. Beneath them, fixed across the rafters, is a sheet called underlay, also known as felt, and on top of that run battens, the thin timber strips that the tiles hang on. Water that gets past a tile is meant to meet the underlay and run down it to the gutter.
That is its job, and it is a back-up. Underlay is not designed to face the weather day after day. Open to the sky it is exposed to rain, wind and sun, and it can be torn or lifted by a gust. A gap that shows black felt has therefore changed what is holding the weather out.
Older roofs may have a different arrangement. Some have no underlay at all, in which case a gap shows bare batten or boards. Flat roofs are a separate case, since felt there is the covering itself. If the surface you are seeing is on a flat roof, our roof repairs page sets out how those are assessed, and the repair is different.
Why the gap has opened
Several things can leave a hole through which the underlay is visible. Finding which one is the first job, because it decides the repair.
| Cause | What it points to |
|---|---|
| Tile or slate slipped | Failed nail or clip; neighbours may follow |
| Tile cracked and fallen | Impact, frost or an old brittle tile |
| Ridge or verge section lost | Mortar or fixings gone, so the next gust takes more |
| Wind lift along an edge | Loose fixings along the whole run |
| Damage from a branch or aerial | A one-off, kept to one spot |
Where the gap is a single slate, our page on slipped slate repair explains when a whole slate goes back and when it is replaced. If the missing piece is at the ridge or a verge, those edges are worth looking at more widely, because they are the parts a gale reaches first.
A gap in a repaired patch sometimes shows that the earlier repair was done with a mismatched tile or without fixing it properly. The survey looks at that too.
What to do now and what not to do
The felt may be holding for the moment, but its edges can lift in wind and the gap lets in water along every nail line. It is worth acting quickly without taking a risk.
- Photograph the gap from the ground, zoomed in, and the roof around it.
- Note any damp patch on a ceiling or in the loft, and where it sits compared with the gap.
- Pick up any fallen tile pieces carefully and keep them. They help us match the replacement.
- Ring for a survey, and if rain is forecast, ask about a temporary cover.
Do not climb on the roof, do not lay a plastic sheet over it yourself, and do not push the felt back down with a broom from a ladder. A wet roof and a wet ladder are a poor pairing, which our page on fixing your own roof explains.
A tarpaulin is a stopgap, fixed over the whole area and past the damage on every side. It is not a repair, and it must be checked after every gale. The next stage is to put the missing piece back with a matching tile or slate, checking that the underlay and batten below it are sound.
Repair, rules and insurance
If only the covering is missing, the repair is simple: a matching tile or slate fixed in place. If the underlay has torn or the batten has rotted, a small patch is cut out and renewed first, with the new underlay lapped properly under the course above. Where the felt is perished over a wide area, the honest answer may be a larger job, and you will see the photographs before you choose.
On the rules, patching one gap is nowhere near re-roofing. The Planning Portal, for England, treats work as needing no application while it affects less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof. Wales starts from a different place: for a bigger job there, the Welsh Government expects Building Regulations approval in most situations, so we would begin with a word to the council's building control service.
If wind or a storm took the covering, the Financial Ombudsman Service usually looks at expert reports and photos when it reviews a complaint. Your insurer should hear about the damage before anything permanent is done, so keep the receipts and the pictures together. What you receive after the survey is a single written total.
