In brief
On an industrial roof the question is less who and more how. Anyone, tradesperson or tenant, who steps on the sheets themselves is at risk, because a profiled sheet can be slick when damp, thin where it has rusted, and the plastic rooflight panels in it are fragile. HSE says "AC roofs are always fragile". So access is planned before the visit: a platform, a walkway or edge protection, and a named person who knows the route.
Why the roof surface cannot carry a person on trust
An industrial roof looks like a floor from a ladder, and it is not one. Steel sheets are light, fixed along their edges, and span between purlins, the beams across the building. Between those beams the sheet gives. A rusted sheet gives more, and a damp one is slick.
The rooflights are a danger of their own. They are plastic or glass-reinforced panels set into the roof to let daylight in, and they look much the same as the sheets either side of them once dirt and moss have settled. Old ones weather and can break under a person's weight without warning. Our guide to fragile roofs and rooflights gives the longer account.
On a roof of asbestos cement the answer is stronger still. HSE's guidance states: "AC roofs are always fragile". A new coat of paint or a tidy surface changes nothing. Nobody is allowed to rely on a look from the edge to decide that a sheet will carry them, and the survey assumes no sheet will.
This is the starting position on every roof of this kind. The rest is about how people reach the work without standing on the surface at all.
The people who may be on the roof, and why
A roof visit needs a reason and a plan. These are the people for whom access is normally arranged, each with their own conditions:
- the roofer carrying out the survey or the repair, from a platform, tower or edge-protected route
- an engineer servicing plant, using a fixed walkway or a path laid on the roof for the purpose
- a surveyor or insurer's representative, accompanied by someone who knows the route
- a specialist, such as an asbestos contractor, when the building calls for one
Everyone else stays off. That includes staff who fancy a look at a leak, a tenant retrieving a ball and a contractor who has come for a different job. A roof hatch left unlocked is an invitation, so the key is kept by a named person, and the hatch is secured again after every visit.
Before the work starts, the person managing the project should say in writing who may go up, for what and by which route. Our answer on when a job needs a principal contractor covers who holds that role once several firms are involved.
How we reach the work without loading the sheets
We begin at ground level and under the roof. Standing on the floor of the unit, we can see the underside of the sheets, the laps and the fixings, and from a tower or a mobile platform at the eaves we see the lower edge close up. No sheet takes weight in that first look.
When the work has to be done from the roof itself, the plan covers:
- a route from the access point to the work, laid with boards that spread the load and rest on the supports
- edge protection or a platform at every open edge and every opening
- covers or guards over any rooflight on or near the route
- a rule that nobody steps off the route
HSE's instruction for a building that went up, or was refurbished, before 2000 is to "assume that there is asbestos in it", and that raises the bar before anyone climbs. Our answer on assuming asbestos in a unit roof explains the survey. You see photographs of the route and of anything we find, and the quote that follows is a single written total with the access built in.
Which rules change at the Welsh line
Roof safety rules do not stop at the Welsh border. HSE's fragility statement for asbestos cement, and CDM 2015, are Great Britain rules, so an industrial roof in Herefordshire and one in Powys are treated alike on the question of who may stand on them. Only the paperwork around the job changes:
- In England, the Planning Portal frames its no-application test around less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof, and it speaks of houses.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says re-roofing needs Building Regulations approval in most situations.
- In England and in Wales, a scaffold over a pavement needs a licence from the council for the road, and the fee and notice period differ by council.
Regulation 15(5) of CDM 2015 makes a construction phase plan a duty before a lone contractor sets up the site, and access is a main part of that plan. Our commercial roofing page shows how a survey fits into the whole job. When the work ends, the roof is swept clear and the waste is taken away.
