In brief
Yes, you can repair or re-cover a roof in a National Landscape (the new name for an AONB). The designation removes certain permitted development rights, so some jobs need a planning application. In England it removes the dormer right only. In Wales it also removes the right to insert a new roof light. The decision belongs to your local planning authority, never to the National Landscape team.
What the National Landscape label means
From November 2023 every Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty took the working name National Landscape. Herefordshire Council's page on them says the legal designation "remains unchanged". The council counts two inside Herefordshire: one around the Malvern Hills, the other along the Wye, and the Wye one reaches across the border into Monmouthshire.
The label is a mark on the map, and it makes nobody a planning authority. Its own planning page puts it plainly: "It is the responsibility of the individual Local Planning Authorities to make decisions about planning applications, not the National Landscape Team or Partnership." For a house in its Herefordshire part that authority is Herefordshire Council, and for the rest it is the Forest of Dean or Malvern Hills district council.
The first call for a roof job is therefore to the council that covers your address. Ask them to confirm the boundary at your own address, because a line on a map can split a village and your neighbour may sit on the far side of it. What the line changes is set out next, country by country, because England and Wales treat it differently.
In England: dormers lose their right, re-roofing does not
In England the 2015 Order counts a National Landscape as article 2(3) land, alongside National Parks, World Heritage Sites and conservation areas. The effect on a roof is narrow:
- A dormer (Class B, an addition that enlarges the roof space) has no permitted development right there, so it needs a planning application.
- Re-covering falls under Class C, which has no article 2(3) exclusion, so swapping one covering for another on a house is normally permitted development.
- A roof window also falls under Class C, with conditions of its own, set out in our guide to roof window permission.
Building Regulations run on their own track. Under the Planning Portal's test, 25 per cent of the total building envelope and 50 per cent of the roof are the two limits. Stay "less than" both and an application is normally not needed. A second trigger is a new covering whose weight rises by 15 per cent or more, which makes a structural check part of the job. Flats have no householder permitted development rights at all, and a listed house needs listed building consent as well.
In Wales: roof lights and dormers lose their right
In Wales the 1995 Order, as amended there, treats a National Landscape as article 1(5) land. That removes more than it does in England:
- A dormer has no permitted development right (Class B.1(g)).
- A new roof light has none either (Class C.1(d)), so it needs planning permission.
- Removing a chimney is not permitted development there (Class C.1(c)).
A plain change of covering is still normally permitted development, on one condition. Under C.2(a), the materials "so far as practicable match" the appearance of the existing dwellinghouse. Slate swapped for a visibly different tile is where that condition bites, and it is worth a call to the council first.
For Building Regulations, the Welsh Government says re-roofing "will need Building Regulations approval" in most situations, so we check with the council's building control team before we start.
The Wye Valley's Welsh side lies in Monmouthshire. Monmouthshire's Duty Planning Officer (01633 644831) answers questions about whether a job needs permission. For a house inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, ask the National Park Authority instead.
How we survey a house in a protected landscape
We start at the skyline, with the ridge, verges and chimney, then work down the slopes. Each fault is photographed, so you and the council can look at the same evidence. We match the repair to how the house was built, which in a protected landscape means respecting the covering and fixings it already has.
Before a price is agreed, we tell you which of three situations you are in:
- A repair or like-for-like re-cover that normally needs no planning application on your side of the border.
- A job that needs an application, such as a dormer, or a new roof light in Wales.
- A job where the answer turns on a listing or a direction, so the council's reply is needed first.
Where an Article 4 direction may apply, our page on Article 4 directions and roofs shows how to ask. If the house is in an older village centre, find out whether it is in a Herefordshire conservation area. Our work across Hereford and both sides of the border includes those checks, and we hold off ordering slate, tile or lead until the council has replied.
