A stain on the lining under a roof window sends the hand straight to the sealant tube. That may not be the right first move. The wet might be rain getting past the flashing, a worn rubber seal on the sash, moisture that formed on cold glass inside the room, or a pool of water backing up on the slope above the frame.
Each of these looks alike from below and is cured in a different way. The order of checking matters, because the simple causes should be ruled out before anyone strips tiles or orders a new unit.
This post walks through the four causes in the order we look at them on a survey, with the signs that point to each and the repair that follows. It ends with the point where a repair stops making sense and a swap is the better buy, and with the border rules that bite once a window is replaced.
Where is the wet coming from?
Before anything is touched, find out whether the water is coming in or forming indoors. Condensation and a leak can leave the same stain on the lining, and treating one as the other wastes a scaffold. Look at the timing, the place and the weather.
| What you see | Likely source | First check |
|---|---|---|
| Drips in heavy rain only, at a corner of the frame | Flashing or a gap in the covering | The tiles round the frame, from the loft and from outside |
| Beads on the glass or damp on the sill on cold mornings | Condensation | Whether the room is damp and the window clear by midday |
| A wet line along the lower edge of the sash | A worn seal or a blocked drain channel | The seal itself, and the channel under it |
| Wet only after a long spell of rain, with leaves above | Debris holding water against the head | The slope above the window |
A dry loft is a useful clue. Go up with a torch and look at the timbers beside the recess, the underlay and the insulation. If those are dry and the stain is only on the lining, the water is probably forming indoors. If the timber is dark or the insulation is wet, water is entering and you need the roof checked.
Photograph the stain, and ring its edge in pencil with the date beside it. A ring that grows after rain points to a leak, while one that appears and dries within the day does not.
Flashing: the metal that seals the frame into the roof
The flashing is the metalwork that runs round the frame and shoots rain onto the covering below. It is the most likely route in for a roof window that has leaked since it was fitted, and also the one that is easiest to get wrong, because it has to match the covering. Our guide to flashing kits for tiles and slate explains why one kit does not suit every roof.
What goes wrong, in the order we find it:
- A kit made for one profile, fitted to a different covering, so the gutter pieces do not lap properly
- Tiles or slates cut short at the side, leaving the flashing without cover
- Metal that has lifted or been pulled by wind at a corner
- Sealant used to fill a gap that should have been closed with a lapped piece of metal
- Moss or debris sitting in the side channels and pushing water over the edge
MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing "can last for over 80 years", but that is a hedge about lead done well, and a flashing kit is worth only what the laying of it is worth. A bead of sealant can hold for a season and then fail, which brings the stain back.
A proper repair strips the covering back to the frame, checks the underlay and batten ends for rot, relays the flashing in the correct order from the bottom up, and rebuilds the covering over it. Photographs at each stage show the underlay dressed into the recess before it disappears beneath the tiles.
Seals, glazing and the opening sash
A roof window has rubber or foam seals round the sash that close against the frame, and a drainage channel at the base that carries away whatever gets past them. Over the years the seals harden, shrink or tear, and the drainage points can fill with dust and cobwebs.
Signs the seals have failed rather than the flashing:
- The stain is along the bottom or sides of the sash and not at the corners of the frame
- Water appears when the window is shut, and not after it has been left open
- You can see a gap, a kink or a shiny flat patch in the seal when the sash is open
- The drain holes at the base of the frame are clogged with grit
Replacement seals are sold for roof windows by model, so it is worth taking a note of the label on the frame, which can be on the inside of the sash or the frame itself. A fresh seal and a clear drain channel can cure this fault without touching the roof.
A cracked pane is different. If the outer pane has a crack, or the sealed unit has misted between the layers, the glazing unit itself needs replacing. That is a window repair, not a roof repair, and the frame and flashing can stay.
Older windows can have a frame that has warped, so that the sash no longer closes evenly. Then a new seal will not close the gap, and the choice moves toward a new window, as the last section describes.
Condensation that looks like a leak
Warm air carries moisture, and a roof window is a cold surface in a warm room. The moisture turns to water on the glass and the frame, runs down, and soaks the sill. It does not mean rain is coming in. It is common in bathrooms, kitchens and bedrooms with a lot of drying or breathing.
Look for these differences from a leak:
- Beads form on the room side of the glass, never the outer side
- The wet is worst on cold mornings and clears as the day warms
- It appears in dry weather as well as wet
- The loft timber beside the recess is dry
The cure is to deal with the air and not the roof: let the room ventilate, keep the trickle vent or the top flap open for a spell each day, and keep bathroom and kitchen extractors clean and running. Our guide to condensation on roof windows goes into detail, and the same page explains what is normal and what is not.
Condensation can also show up as a sign of a different fault. If the insulation round the recess has slipped, or the lining is cold, the room-side surfaces can sweat and run onto the sill. A roofer looking from the loft sees that straight away.
Where condensation is the cause, replacing flashing will not cure it. That is why we check inside first and photograph the glass at the time of day it is wet.
Blocked drainage above and around the frame
A roof window sits in the path of every drop that comes down the slope above it. Leaves, moss, grit and bird debris collect against the upper edge of the frame, where they hold water like a dam. Rain that should run round the window then banks up and finds the smallest gap in the flashing or the seal.
Look for these on a dry day, from a safe place:
- Moss or leaf litter lying against the head of the frame
- A valley or gutter feeding straight onto the window, loaded with debris
- A tile slipped or broken above the frame, sending water to one spot
- A branch or a satellite fixing that drips onto the glass
None of this requires anyone to climb the roof. Binoculars from the lawn, or a view from the next window, show a good deal of it. Clearing a slope is a job for someone with roof access, not a ladder on the glass, because the glazing is not made to take weight.
We would also look at the gutters below. Brett Martin gives the guide for fall as "1mm for every 600mm", and a gutter that has slipped holds water against the eaves and splashes up the slope. The roof window itself may not cause that, but it takes the blame when the stain appears on the lining.
If clearing the debris stops the problem, that is the smallest bill. If the stain returns after a clear spell and a fresh rain, the flashing or seal is the next place to look.
When to repair and when to replace the window
Most of these faults are repairs, and a replacement is only the honest answer when the unit itself has failed. Warped frames, misted or cracked glazing, rotten timber round the recess and a window that is long past its useful life all point that way. Where the cause turns out to be flashing or debris, the quote is for that smaller job.
If a replacement is the answer, the rules that apply depend on the nation the house is in:
- In England, a new roof window falls under Approved Document L Table 4.2 and has to show a figure of 1.4, or else WER Band B.
- In Wales, the Welsh Table 4.1 asks the same of a roof window.
- For a listed house in England, listed building consent is needed under section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990; in Wales, the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 sections 88 and 89 apply.
- In Wales, a conservation area, a National Park or a National Landscape removes a new roof light from permitted development, so planning permission enters the picture.
For the permitted development side, our roof window planning guide sets out both nations. A swap itself is a short job once the cause is known.
If the fault began soon after a recent fitting, the Citizens Advice consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133 gives advice on your rights, and the Welsh-speaking adviser is on 0808 223 1144. Our Velux and skylights page describes the work we do on roof windows.
