The age of a house points to the faults to look for before anyone climbs a ladder. A roof laid with sandstone tilestones, one laid with clay plain tiles and one laid with concrete interlocking tiles are three different structures. Each fails in its own way and on its own timetable, and each wants its own repair.
This post therefore sorts the faults by what is on the roof, not by postcode. The covering matters more than the street, and nobody can read it better than you can from the pavement with a phone camera. Where a Hereford locality adds something firm, such as a conservation area or a listed house, it gets a mention in the last section.
The work of Horizon Roofing Hereford starts where every survey starts, at the skyline: the ridge along the top, the verge at the gable, the chimney and the valleys. Those are the joints where a house's age can show, because they hold the mortar, the lead and the fixings, and each of those ages at its own rate. The post is for houses in Hereford and across the English borderlands. For a wider tour of materials, our guide to roof types across Herefordshire covers the county.
Read the covering before you guess the age
Start with the material, because a covering narrows the possibilities faster than a date on a deed. Looking from the opposite pavement, take in the colour and the grain of the slope. Then check the edge at the verge, where the thickness of the tiles or slates shows in profile. The table pairs each common covering with what to look for and the lifespan quoted by a named source.
| Covering | Look for | Published lifespan |
|---|---|---|
| Clay plain tile | Small, slightly curved, orange to brown, with a weathered face | Marley: the BRE set a minimum life expectancy of 60 years for clay |
| Welsh slate | Thin, flat, grey to blue, laid in even courses | HomeBuilding: "100+ years" for Welsh slate |
| Fibre cement tile | Thin, flat, even grey, laid in neat courses | HomeBuilding: 30 to 40 years |
| Concrete tile | Larger, flat or profiled, grey to brown, with a sandy surface | Marley: around 60 years; HomeBuilding: 40 to 50 years |
Read these as typical ranges, not promises (our answer on how long a roof will last goes further), and a roof that has been rebedded and refixed along the way can outlast its range. Marley adds that its own figure "is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity". Note that the two concrete figures come from two different sources, so quote both rather than pick the kinder one.
Stone tilestones and the black-and-white houses
Tilestones are slabs of local sandstone split into roofing tiles. The county's stone atlas, edited by the British Geological Survey, names the St Maughans sandstones around the Golden Valley as where Herefordshire's stone roofing mainly came from. It records flagstone roofs on older cottages in Longtown, and flagstones from the Raglan Mudstone on older cottages in Kington.
The same atlas describes the villages of timber-framed houses lying to the north-west of Hereford, "notably Eardisland, Pembridge, Almeley, Dilwyn, Yarpole and Weobley". Their big outside chimney stacks are, in its words, "commonly of local sandstone". A house with a stone stack and a heavy stone roof was built to a pattern that a standard repair does not fit.
SPAB, the society that advises on old buildings, says the slate and stone roofs of this region "are predominantly double-lapped": each slab overlaps the course below and the one beneath that. It also laments how often roofs have been given different stones, or been re-covered in slates or imitation stone slates. Two cautions follow:
- A replacement slab that does not match in thickness or lap can leave a gap that lets rain past the course below.
- When a supplier says matching stone cannot be had, SPAB's advice is that such a claim "should always be checked with the quarries", so ask the quarry itself.
For the repair itself, we lift the slabs around the fault, keep every sound one and re-lay them in their original courses. A stack with a cracked collar or a loose pot is inspected at the same visit.
Clay tiles and slate: nails, courses and ridges
The same atlas credits Raglan mudstone clay with feeding Herefordshire's brick, tile and pipeworks trades, which it calls famous. A house roofed in clay plain tiles sits comfortably with that history and rewards a like-for-like repair. Welsh slate is the other long-lived covering on older houses. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate "100+ years", Spanish slate "75-100 years" and reclaimed Welsh slate "50-80 years", and SPAB says "a well-slated roof" is "likely to be more than 100 years".
Both coverings hang on small fixings that age faster than the material does. A survey photograph of these roofs tends to show the following faults:
- A slate that has slipped a few centimetres because the nail that carried it has rusted through, leaving a gap and a strip of underlay in view.
- Clay tiles that have shed their faces in frost, so the surface flakes while the body of the tile is still sound.
- A ridge whose bedding mortar has cracked and let a capping tile rock.
- A verge where the cement fillet has opened away from the edge tile.
Cupa, a slate maker, recommends keeping hook fixings off any pitch under 25 degrees. Where a roof has been patched with a different fixing in the past, the survey checks that too, because mixed fixings on one slope can point to repairs made at different times by different hands. The repair as surveyed is priced as one written total handed to you afterwards, and the site is left tidy.
Concrete tiles, ridge mortar and underlay
A concrete-tiled roof is where bedding mortar matters most. The standard for fixing tiles is BS 5534:2014+A2:2018, which is current. Marley says "Installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law", and it explains that the 2015 amendments "made it clear that mortar could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". Mortar remains allowed. What has changed is that a ridge fixed today is held mechanically as well as bedded. Where an older ridge relies on mortar alone, a loose cap suggests the bedding has let go.
If you are weighing a different covering, weight matters. In England the Planning Portal says approval is needed if "You use a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more." That falls under Building Regulations rather than planning, and a structural check goes with it.
Underlay is the other age clue, and it sits in the loft:
- HR underlay, short for high resistance, blocks the passage of vapour, so Marley says it needs eaves ventilation: 25mm along the eaves for pitches of 15 degrees or less, and 10mm above 15 degrees.
- Where the underlay is air-permeable and the ceiling below is tightly sealed, Marley accepts what it calls "fortuitous ventilation" at the eaves, provided third-party certification is met.
- A felt that has gone brittle, torn at the battens or hung loose is a sign of age in itself.
Flat extensions, garages and outbuildings
Some houses carry an add-on that is younger than the main roof and wears out on a shorter clock. A flat-roofed kitchen extension, a garage or a porch uses a different covering, and each covering has its own published lifespan:
| Covering | HomeBuilding | Less |
|---|---|---|
| Torch-on felt | 10 to 15 years | 10 to 20 years |
| EPDM rubber | 25 to 30 years | 30 to 50 years |
| GRP fibreglass | 25 to 30 years | 25 to 40 years |
| Lead | 60 to 100 years | 50 to 100 years |
The two sources disagree, so a flat roof near the lower end of both has earned a closer look. A felt roof laid in one decade and left alone shows its age at the upstand (the short wall at the point the flat roof abuts the main house) and at the seams, where blisters, ponding and splits begin.
Treat any corrugated sheet roof on a garage or shed with care. HSE says: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." It also says "AC roofs are always fragile", so nobody should walk on one. Keep clear of broken sheets, and have the survey done from the ground first. Any asbestos cement removal is planned as its own job, not tacked on to a tile repair, and the first step is to tell us what the sheets look like and when the building went up, so the survey can be planned around it.
Streets with designations: check before you repair
Herefordshire Council says there are 64 conservation areas in the county, and several cover Hereford localities. The table gives the areas that touch five localities, with the years from the council's own list of designation dates. Listed examples come from Historic England list records.
| Locality | Conservation area and year | Listed example |
|---|---|---|
| Aylestone Hill | Aylestone Hill, 1969 | Elmhurst, Grade II |
| Broomy Hill | Broomy Hill, 1975 | Oakleigh Cottage, Grade II |
| Widemarsh | Widemarsh Common, 1975 | Moor House, Grade II |
| Bartonsham | Hafod Road, 1992; Hampton Park, 1969 | St Giles' Hospital, Grade II |
| Huntington | Huntington, 1975 | Huntington Court, Grade II |
In England, work on a listed house needs listed building consent if it affects the building's special interest (Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, section 7). A conservation area also changes what can be done with dormers. Before ordering any change to the roof, settle the Article 4 point for your road with Herefordshire Council.
Whatever the street, the covering you can see is the better guide. Our answer on whether your house is in a Herefordshire conservation area shows how to check the council's list, and the survey photographs the underlay, the fixings and the covering, and the pictures stay with you. If your house is listed or sits in one of these areas, tell us when you book, and send the council's wording for any condition that applies.
