01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Insurer reports

Roof condition reports for insurers and the Ombudsman

A roof condition report records the covering as it stood on the day of inspection, in dated photographs and plain notes, so you, your insurer and the Ombudsman all read the same evidence.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

After wind damage, the argument that follows may not be about whether a tile is broken. It is about why. Was the covering sound until the gust took it, or had it been slipping for years? An insurer wants an answer, and so does the Financial Ombudsman Service if a complaint ever reaches it. The Ombudsman says it takes into account your property's condition at the time the storm damage happened, and that to judge it, the Ombudsman will usually turn to "expert reports and photos".

A roof condition report is the document that answers the question. We go up the roof, work from the ridge down, and photograph each part before anyone touches it. The notes say what we saw, the spot it was seen and the state it was in, in words a loss adjuster, a surveyor or a complaints handler can follow without ever having stood on your lawn.

This guide sets out what such a report holds, which photographs help, how storm and wear are told apart, and what to do first if water is coming in. It also covers the rules that apply once a repair grows larger, labelled England or Wales. For the wider picture, see our roof inspections page.

What the report is for, and what it is not

A condition report is a record, not a verdict. It describes the roof at a fixed date. It does not decide whether a policy responds, because that call belongs to your insurer and rests on the wording of your policy. What the report can do is remove doubt about the facts: which slates were slipped, which ridge tiles sat in sound mortar, which flashings were already lifting before the weather arrived.

That matters because of how insurers reason. The Financial Ombudsman Service says an insurer must show that an exclusion applies, and gives an inspection report as one way of doing it. It also says it expects the insurer to check all parts of your policy, not only the storm damage part. A report taken close to the event gives both sides a fixed picture to argue from, instead of memories and guesses made months afterwards.

There are two moments when a report earns its place:

  • straight after damage, to fix the condition of the roof on the day
  • before any trouble, when a roof is in doubt, so an earlier record exists if a claim follows later

The report is written by the roofer who inspected, from what was in front of them on the roof. The claim itself is a matter for you and your insurer, and the report is simply the roof's side of the story, handed over in a form that anyone can read.

What a condition report records, part by part

We follow one order on every roof, because a fixed order leaves no gaps. The first look goes to the skyline, then the survey descends: the ridge, the verges along the gables, the chimney with its flashings and flaunching (the mortar that beds the pots), the valleys, then the main slopes, then the eaves and gutters. Flat roofs and roof windows get entries of their own.

For each part, the report gives a position, a condition and a photograph. Position matters more than people expect: "slipped slate, left slope, fourth course up from the eaves" can be found again, while "some loose slates" cannot. A reader a year later, standing in the same garden, can match the note to the roof.

What a condition report holds for each part
PartWhat is recorded
Ridge and hipsBedding, fixings, any gaps or loose capping
VergesMortar or dry-fix caps, edge tiles lifting or sound
ChimneyFlashing, soakers, pointing, flaunching, pot fixing
SlopesCracked, slipped or missing pieces, with course positions
Eaves and guttersFall, joints, blockages, fascia and soffit condition

The report also notes what could not be seen. A section hidden behind a stack or under a thick growth of moss is recorded as unseen, never passed as sound. A report that admits its blind spots is easier to rely on than one that pretends to see everything, and it tells you where a second look may be needed.

Photographs that carry weight

In these cases the Financial Ombudsman Service will usually turn to "expert reports and photos", so how the photographs are taken matters as much as how many there are. A close-up of a broken tile tells a reader nothing about where it sits. Three framings do the job together.

  1. A wide shot of the whole elevation, so the reader can place everything else.
  2. A medium shot of the part, such as the chimney and the slope around it.
  3. A close shot of the fault itself, sharp enough to show an old crack face, rust on a nail or fresh breakage.

Old damage and new damage look different, and the close shot is where that shows. A broken edge that is dark and mossy has been there a while. A pale, clean break has not. The report says what the photograph shows and leaves the reader to see it, rather than telling them what to conclude.

If you can take photos yourself before we arrive, stand on the ground and shoot each elevation of the house. Do not climb up for them. Keep the files as they come off the phone, because the date and time stored with each picture are part of the record, and crops or filters can strip them. Our guide to why photos matter on a roof inspection explains how we shoot the roof itself, and what each picture is for.

Storm damage and wear are not the same thing

Insurers separate damage from sudden weather and damage from age, and the report is where that split becomes visible. On storms, the Financial Ombudsman Service describes a storm as violent winds that usually bring rain, hail or snow, then adds that some storms bring no high winds at all, and that rain, hail or snowfall can be enough without any gale. Some insurers, it says, accept only winds beyond a chosen point on the Beaufort Scale as storm-force, and the Ombudsman factors that scale in when it looks at a case, so a report that records wind direction and debris is useful.

A condition report cannot prove a storm happened. It can record what a storm would be expected to leave behind, and what it would not:

  • fresh breaks and clean edges on slates or tiles, with no moss over them
  • debris on the ground below, in the line the wind would carry it
  • displaced pieces that all lean one way, matching one side of the house
  • against that, rusted nail heads, brittle underlay, crumbling mortar or a sagging ridge, which build up over seasons

Both kinds of finding can sit on one roof. A sound roof can be damaged by wind, and so can a worn one. The report lists each finding separately so the insurer can weigh them, and so you are not asked to prove more than the evidence allows. Where a finding is uncertain, the wording says so plainly instead of picking a side.

The first steps if water is coming in

These steps are general good practice for a damaged roof. The order matters, because a repair cannot be undone for the photographs afterwards.

  1. Make the room safe. Put a bucket under a drip, move belongings, and keep people out of a room where a ceiling is bulging with water.
  2. Photograph the ceiling, the loft and the outside of the house before any of it is moved or cleared away.
  3. Phone your insurer before booking any lasting repair, and find out what paperwork they want to see. A temporary cover to stop further damage is a separate matter, and its receipts should be kept.
  4. Keep every receipt, and write down the date and the weather when you first noticed the damage.
  5. Stay off the roof. Our guide to making a roof safe after damage explains tarpaulins and temporary covers.

Once the insurer is involved, a report from a roofer is something you can send with the photographs, or hold ready if they ask. Whether the claim is covered is for the insurer and your policy to settle.

On cost, the average roof survey, says MyJobQuote, is around £300, with a basic visual roof inspection at £100 to £200 and a full roof survey at £250 to £400. Our page on roof survey cost sets out what moves a price, and why one written total follows the survey rather than an estimate over the phone.

When you and the insurer disagree

If an insurer turns down a claim or offers less than the repair needs, you complain to the insurer first. The Financial Ombudsman Service takes complaints on 0800 023 4567. Its guidance says you can go to the Ombudsman if you have no final response within eight weeks, and the time limit is six months from the final response. The Ombudsman covers England and Wales alike. In Wales, Citizens Advice also has a Welsh-speaking adviser on 0808 223 1144, and its consumer helpline, on either side of the border, is 0808 223 1133.

A condition report with dated photographs gives a complaint handler something solid to read. The full guidance is on the Ombudsman's storm damage page.

Once a repair is agreed, the size of the job decides which rules apply:

  • In England, the Planning Portal's test for re-covering has two limbs: "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" affected, and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof" affected. Pass both and no application is normally required.
  • In England, approval is also needed when a heavier new covering adds weight "by 15 per cent or more", the Planning Portal says.
  • In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."

Before a larger repair the first call goes to building control in the right country, either the local council's service or a registered building control approver, and we make that call before any work is booked in.

Condition reports and insurers: your questions

Should the report be done before the roof is repaired?

Yes, where it is safe to wait. The report fixes the condition of the roof on a given day, and permanent repairs change that. If water is coming in, make the room safe, take photographs and arrange a temporary cover first, and keep every receipt. Tell your insurer before lasting work.

Will my insurer accept a report written by a roofer?

That is for your insurer to decide. The Financial Ombudsman Service usually turns to "expert reports and photos", so a dated report with clear pictures is useful to hold. Some insurers send their own surveyor as well, and the two reports can then be read side by side.

Can a report say whether a roof was damaged by a storm?

It records what is on the roof: fresh breaks, debris, displaced pieces, and signs of long wear. It cannot prove the weather. The Financial Ombudsman Service accepts that rain alone can amount to a storm, so the insurer weighs the whole of the evidence, new damage and old together.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing