01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Historic roof checks

Inspecting a listed or historic roof without harming it

An old roof is part of the building's record as well as its shelter. This guide covers looking at one without damage, what the findings mean, and the consent rules in England and Wales.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

A listed or historic roof asks for a different kind of survey. The covering may be the original stone, laid by hand from a quarry a few miles away. The timbers beneath may be centuries old, and the pegs, joints and torching in the roof space are part of what makes the building what it is. Each step onto such a roof risks a cracked tilestone, so the aim is to learn as much as possible while touching as little as possible.

The same care applies to the paperwork. Looking at a roof is one thing and altering it is another, and the law treats them differently. A repair that would pass without comment on a modern house can need consent on a listed one, wherever it stands along the border.

The sections that follow cover how to read the materials, how to look without harm, what the findings lead to, and the consent routes in each country. For the full range of surveys, see our roof inspections page.

Listed, historic and in a conservation area

These three descriptions overlap but are not the same, and each brings its own question.

  • A listed building is protected by statute. The consent rules cover all of it, inside and out, roof included.
  • A building in a conservation area is not listed by that fact, but the area brings extra planning controls. Herefordshire's own page says "There are currently 64 conservation areas in Herefordshire."
  • A building called historic may be neither, in which case ordinary rules apply, though the roof still repays gentle handling.

For listed buildings, the law differs between the two countries.

Listed building consent, by country
CountryLawWhat it controls
EnglandPlanning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, section 7Works "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest"
WalesHistoric Environment (Wales) Act 2023, section 88, in force from 4 November 2024Works "for the alteration or extension of a listed building in any way that would affect its character"; authorised through listed building consent under section 89

A listed house keeps its permitted development rights for roof alterations, in England and in Wales, though it also needs listed building consent. Planning permission and listed building consent are separate decisions, so approval of one says nothing about the other.

If you are unsure whether a house is listed, the council can tell you, and so can the listing entry for the address. For a historic house that is not listed, the same careful approach pays off, because the roof can be the one part that has never been altered. Mention the age of the building when you book, so the visit is planned around the lightest method.

A conservation area can also carry an Article 4 direction, which withdraws specified permitted development rights across a defined area. Before planning work, ask your council if a direction is in force on your street.

Reading the covering before you touch it

A survey of a historic roof starts by identifying what the roof is made of, because each material has its own weak points. In the Herefordshire building stone atlas, the St Maughans Formation sandstones are named as "the principal sources of Herefordshire stone roofing", which a small number of quarries still work. Downton Castle Sandstone has been used historically as a tilestone, and brownstones were quarried for tilestones and dimension stone. Across the north-west corner, the timber-framed houses of the Black and White Villages, "notably Eardisland, Pembridge, Almeley, Dilwyn, Yarpole and Weobley", stand on a different roofing tradition again, and each building should be read for itself.

SPAB's technical note on slate and stone covers the border counties. It says that Welsh slate and stone roofs "are predominantly double-lapped". In a double-lapped roof each piece sits over a gap in the course below, so a displaced stone opens a route that is hard to see. SPAB adds that "there are some purple types in Herefordshire", so colour and texture vary from one quarry to the next.

What we note on a first look:

  • the covering: stone tilestone, flagstone, slate, clay tile or something later
  • whether part of the roof has been renewed in a different material
  • stones that are flaking in layers where frost has got in
  • slipped or missing pieces, and whether the courses still run straight
  • a sag in the ridge or the slope, a sign that the timbers below are moving
  • moss, ivy or plants rooted in the joints

Lifespan figures need care. SPAB writes that a well-slated roof has a life "likely to be more than 100 years". Any view on how long a stone tilestone roof will last should come from the evidence on that roof itself.

Looking without harm

The safest inspection of a delicate roof is the one with the least weight on it. We start from the ground and from neighbouring vantage points, then go inside, and go up only where a fault needs a closer look.

The options run from lightest to heaviest:

  1. Binoculars or a long lens from the ground, to read the courses, ridge and chimney stacks.
  2. The loft or roof space, where daylight through a slope, stained timbers and damp patches show faults from underneath with no weight on the covering.
  3. A pole camera or a drone, where height or pitch makes the roof hard to see.
  4. A ladder against the eaves, set with care for the gutter and the covering.
  5. Stepping onto the roof, only where boards or a supported route can spread the load, or where no other method will answer the question.

Our guide to what a roof survey report covers shows how results are set out. On an old house the report is worth keeping, because it joins the record of what has been done to the building.

Inside the roof space, old timbers deserve the same respect as the covering. They are looked at and photographed, and probed only where a soft patch is suspected, with a small tool and a light touch. Torching, the lime mortar pointing between battens that some older roofs carry, is left undisturbed, because pulling at it can bring pieces down into the room below. Photographs are taken wide and then close, with a note of where each was taken, so that a repair can be matched to a position on the roof later.

Gutters, hoppers and rainwater pipes are included. On an old house they may be cast iron, and a failed joint can soak a wall for years before a stain appears.

From findings to repair: matching and supply

On a historic roof repair comes before replacement, and the aim is a repair that matches the existing covering. A cracked stone is replaced with a matching one, a slipped slate is refixed, and a failed flashing is renewed in lead. If a repair will last, repair is what we recommend, and the photographs show the reasons.

The hard part can be supply. SPAB comments: "Unfortunately, many are changed to different stones or even to slates or fake stone slates." It also advises: "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries." So if you are told the original stone cannot be had, ask for that to be confirmed at source before accepting a substitute.

Where reclaimed or new material is used, ask what it is and where it came from. A repair in a different material can alter character, and on a listed building that is the test for consent.

The rules for work to the roof itself differ by country:

  • In England, a new covering for a house falls under permitted development as a rule, with a listed house needing listed building consent in addition.
  • In Wales, permitted development needs the new materials to match the old so far as practicable. A roof light cannot go in as permitted development in a conservation area, a National Park or a National Landscape, and a listed house also requires listed building consent.
  • In England, the Malvern Hills National Landscape says planning decisions rest with the Local Planning Authorities, and not with its own team.

Inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, check with the National Park Authority. Building Regulations on both sides of the border are handled by the council's building control service or a registered building control approver.

Chapels, monuments and roosts

Some historic roofs belong to a place of worship or lie within a scheduled monument, and the route changes with them.

  • In England, Church of England churches in use go through the faculty system instead of listed building consent, while a closed church needs consent.
  • In Wales, a Church in Wales church building in use follows that church's own system.
  • In England, scheduled monument consent is a matter for the Secretary of State.
  • In Wales, the Welsh Ministers receive the application for scheduled monument consent.

For a church or chapel, the first call is the governing body of that church. Which denomination and which use apply decides the route, so the conversation starts there.

Old roof spaces also suit roosting bats. Every bat species is protected, along with its breeding sites and resting places. GOV.UK names repair or replacement of a roof as work that can affect them, and the licensing body is Natural England for an English address and Natural Resources Wales for a Welsh one. If bats turn up during a check, work on that area stops; see our guide to bats found during an inspection.

After the check, you hold a set of dated photographs, a list of what was seen and a view on what is urgent. That record is useful in itself: it supports a consent application, it helps an architect or conservation adviser and it shows the next owner what was found.

On price, MyJobQuote puts a roof survey at around £300 on average, a UK-wide figure and not a Horizon price. A historic roof can cost more or less to look at than that, depending on its height, its access and how much of the roof space can be entered.

Historic roofs: your questions

Does inspecting a listed roof need listed building consent?

Looking at a roof does not alter it, so a survey from the ground, the loft or a camera needs no consent. Lifting stones, removing pieces or repairing in a different material may affect the building's character, and that is what consent covers. Check with the council before anything is lifted or changed.

Where can I see whether my street is in a conservation area?

Ask the council. Herefordshire Council lists its conservation areas, which include Hereford's historic centre, and an Article 4 direction may apply within one. In Wales, conservation areas are designated under Part 4 of the 2023 Act, and the council holds the list for your address.

Can a stone tilestone roof be repaired in slate instead?

It can look like a saving, but SPAB records that many have already been swapped for other stones or slates, and says claims that the original stone is unavailable should be checked with the quarries. Swapping the material on a listed roof can alter its character, so consent is a question to settle first.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing