01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Choosing a covering

Glass or polycarbonate: choosing a conservatory roof

Glass and polycarbonate both let in the light, but they age, weigh and perform differently. Here is how they compare, with the lifespans a published source gives for each.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Anyone replacing a conservatory roof meets the same fork early on: a clear glass roof, or polycarbonate sheet. Polycarbonate costs less to fit and sits lightly on the frame. Glass costs more, lasts longer and behaves better in heat and sound. Neither is right for every conservatory, and the answer depends on what the room is for and what the frame can carry.

This guide sets the two side by side. It leads with the lifespans that HomeBuilding publishes, because they come from one published table, and it keeps the hedges that source attaches to them. It then turns to light, heat, noise and weight, to the Building Regulations that apply to either covering in England and in Wales, and to the points we check on the survey before a covering is recommended.

The service sits on our conservatory roofs page. If you already have polycarbonate and are weighing a change, the page on swapping polycarbonate for glass deals with that move directly.

Three coverings, three lifespans

HomeBuilding's guide to conservatory roof replacement puts a typical life on each of the three coverings an owner is likely to be offered. The polycarbonate wording is its own, the glass and tiled lines come from Roofing Megastore's managing director, and the hedges stay in:

  • Polycarbonate: "a typical lifespan of 10 years".
  • Glass: "likely" to last "in excess of 30 years".
  • Tiled: "typically" lasting "in excess of 50 years".

The gap between the first two is wide, and it is the strongest argument for glass. A polycarbonate roof fitted today could need replacing again while a glass roof from the same year is still in good order.

These are typical figures from a single source. They describe what a roof in ordinary condition might do, not what yours will do, and they carry no guarantee of any kind. A roof on a well-kept frame with sound seals can reach the top of a range, and one on a moving frame with failed seals can fall short of it.

Compare like with like. When a quote states a lifespan, ask which source it comes from and whether it covers the frame as well as the covering.

The tiled figure is here for context. A solid roof is a different build, with its own weight and its own rules, and it is covered on the page about solid tiled conservatory roofs. If a polycarbonate roof is the one you have now, the signs that it is nearing the end are set out in our page on how long polycarbonate lasts.

What a lifespan figure leaves out

A number of years describes the covering. It says little about the parts around it, and those are where trouble tends to start.

  • The bars and capping that hold the covering in place wear on their own timetable.
  • The seals and gaskets along the bars can harden and split long before the sheet or the glass gives up.
  • The joint at the house wall depends on lead, pointing and sealant, which age separately from the roof.
  • The gutter at the eaves has to drain a roof that can shed a lot of rain in a short time.

It follows that a longer-lasting covering fitted on tired bars will not last as long as its figure suggests. Surveying a roof like this, we start with the bars and seals, and we tell you whether they can be reused or ought to be renewed with the new covering. Putting new glass onto old capping is a false economy when the capping is the part that is failing.

Condition also changes how a covering ages. Polycarbonate sheet can scratch and cloud with cleaning and weather, which dulls the room beneath it. Glass keeps its clarity, though a failed seal in a sealed unit can show as misting between the panes. Both are worth raising when the survey is done, and neither shows up in a lifespan table.

Condensation on the inside of the roof is another matter a lifespan table leaves out. It forms on the cold face of either covering in damp weather, and it can look like a leak. We separate the two at the survey, before any covering takes the blame.

Ask whoever quotes what is staying and what is going. A price for the covering alone, on bars that will need replacing next year, is a poor basis for comparison.

Light, heat and sound in the room

The comparison below is general. The exact result depends on the product, the orientation of the room and the way the roof is built.

How the two coverings compare in the room
QuestionPolycarbonateGlass
Weight on the frameLightHeavier
Sound of heavy rainCan carry more of it into the roomTends to be quieter
Heat in summerDepends on tint and buildTints and coatings are available
Heat in winterMultiwall sheet holds someDouble glazed units hold more
CleaningScratches more easilySelf-cleaning coatings exist

HomeBuilding describes polycarbonate as lightweight and easy to install but not as durable as glass or tiled roofs, and says that in some cases it can let in outside noise such as heavy rain. The managing director it quotes points to double glazed glass with an argon filling to help keep heat in, to self-cleaning glass, and to tinted glass where glare is a problem in summer.

If a glass roof is too bright or too hot in July, the cure is chosen at the order stage with the right coating, because fixing it afterwards is harder. A coated or tinted unit costs more than clear glass, so the order stage is also the time to ask what the coating adds to the price. If it is winter cold that you want to beat, the covering is only part of the answer, and a room warmed all year raises questions about the exemption that need asking early.

The rules that apply whichever you choose

The covering is a matter of taste and budget. The approval route is the same for both, and it starts with building control.

  • In England, the Planning Portal's guidance is that any new conservatory roof has to be "structurally safe, energy efficient and properly ventilated", and it must comply with building regulations.
  • In Wales, Welsh Government guidance expects Building Regulations approval for re-roofing in most situations.
  • In England, the energy exemption for a conservatory holds only while every limb of Approved Document L paragraph 0.14 is met, and one limb is that the glazing complies with Part K.
  • In England, Table 4.2 gives a new roof 0.15 and a rooflight 2.2. In Wales, Table 4.1 gives a roof 0.13 and a roof-light 2.2.

So glass is not a way round the rules. Whether a glazed roof counts as a roof or as rooflights for those figures is a question for building control, and the answer decides which line of the table applies.

Building control is a council department, and the private option is to use a registered approver. In England, Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938. Where the property is in Wales, ask the council's building control service.

The weight of the covering matters as well. In England, the Planning Portal's test is whether a new material adds weight "by 15 per cent or more", and Approved Document A uses "more than 15%". Either way, approval is needed. In Wales, the Welsh Approved Document A also says "more than 15%". Moving from polycarbonate to glass is the case where this test comes into play. Planning permission is a separate matter, and the choice of covering does not trigger it.

Weight, the frame and swapping one for the other

Polycarbonate is light, and the frame under it may have been sized for that. Glass is heavier. A frame designed for sheet can carry a glazed roof only if its bars and its connections to the wall and the dwarf walls were built for the extra weight, or can be strengthened.

That is why the move from polycarbonate to glass is never a simple swap of panels:

  1. The bars are checked for size and condition.
  2. The connection to the house wall and the base are inspected.
  3. Building control is asked about the change, since the weight of the covering may rise by more than 15%.
  4. The new bars, units and seals are specified together, never one at a time.

Where strengthening is needed, it is done before the covering goes on. It appears in the photographs and in the written total price, so it never turns up later as an extra.

Any frame that fails those checks is raised with you ahead of agreeing a price, and the choices are set out plainly: strengthen it, use a lighter covering, or look at a different kind of roof altogether.

For the move in the other direction, from glass to sheet, the frame may not be the issue and the lifespan is. A cheaper covering that lasts a third as long comes round for replacement three times as often, and the cost returns with it.

Cost, and how the survey helps you decide

For scale, MyJobQuote puts the 2026 average for replacing a conservatory roof at £3,200 to £6,000. That range comes from an outside source and is not our price, and it does not split by covering. Roof size, covering, frame condition and access move a real job within it or beyond it.

On the survey we look at:

  • the shape and orientation of the roof, and what the room is used for
  • the frame, the bars and the seals, and whether they can be reused
  • the joint at the house wall and the gutter below the eaves
  • the weight the frame can carry, and the rules for your side of the border

You then receive a recommendation with the reasons, photographs of what we found, and one written total price. If polycarbonate is the honest answer for an old frame and a modest budget, we recommend it. If glass is right and the frame needs strengthening first, the price shows that up front.

Where the frame is sound and the budget allows, either covering can be fitted. Where it is not, the survey sets out the options in order. Either way the old covering is taken away and the site is left tidy.

Questions worth putting to any firm that quotes: which covering, which bars stay, how the wall joint is sealed, who speaks to building control, and what the single total includes.

A recommendation should name what it assumes: the covering, whether the bars are staying, and what happens at the wall. When those three are written down, two quotes can be compared fairly.

Glass or polycarbonate questions

Which lasts longer, glass or polycarbonate?

HomeBuilding gives polycarbonate a typical lifespan of 10 years and quotes a roofing retailer's managing director saying glass will likely outlast 30 years. Those are typical ranges from one source, never promises, and the bars, seals and frame around the covering decide how any real roof ages. A survey shows what condition yours is in.

Is a glass roof exempt from Building Regulations?

No. In England, the Planning Portal's guidance covers any new conservatory roof, and the energy exemption in Approved Document L paragraph 0.14 needs every condition met. In Wales, the Welsh Government expects re-roofing to need approval in most situations. Ask building control first, before a covering is ordered.

Can my frame take glass in place of polycarbonate?

Only a survey can say. Glass is heavier, and a frame sized for sheet may need stronger bars or fixings. A covering that adds more than 15% to the weight brings in Building Regulations approval in both countries, so the frame is checked before a price is agreed.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing