01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Asbestos cement roofs

Are asbestos cement roofs fragile?

Yes. HSE puts every asbestos cement roof in the fragile class, however sound a sheet looks from the ground, and none can be trusted with a person's weight.

In brief

Yes. HSE's roof guidance (publication A14) states plainly that "AC roofs are always fragile". Asbestos cement, or AC, is the grey fibre-and-cement sheeting found on older units, farm sheds and garages. Paint, age and a clean surface make no difference to that. Nobody should step on the sheets, and nobody should drill, break or scrub them until the material has been identified. The same HSE guidance covers England and Wales.

What fragile means for a sheet of asbestos cement

Fragile has a plain meaning in roofing: the surface may not hold the weight of a person, and it can give way without warning. HSE applies that word to asbestos cement without exception. Its sentence is "AC roofs are always fragile", and the word that carries the weight is "always".

Asbestos cement sheets are made by pressing cement and asbestos fibre together into corrugated or flat boards. They went onto industrial units, workshops, farm buildings, garages and lean-tos, and it is still found on them.

Because the rule has no conditions, no look from the edge can rescue it. A roof painted last year, a bay with no visible cracks and a sheet that carried a ladder before are all handled alike. Nothing on the surface tells you what a sheet will do under a boot.

None of these makes an AC sheet safe to stand on:

  • a fresh coat of paint or sealant
  • a surface that looks clean and uncracked
  • the fact that someone stood there before
  • a position directly above a purlin, the rail the sheets are fixed to

The plan for any work therefore starts with how people reach the job without touching the sheets at all.

How a survey works when nobody can walk the roof

Our survey of an AC roof is done from below and from the sides. Inside the building we study the underside of each sheet, the laps (the overlaps between neighbouring sheets) and the bolts or screws that hold the sheets down. A stain, a streak of daylight or a drip mark is photographed, with its position noted against the building. Outside, we use a tower or mobile platform set against the eaves, which are the bottom edges of the roof, and keep our feet off the sheets so that they carry no load.

The survey records:

  • cracks, holes and old patches in the sheets
  • the state of the fixings and the laps
  • any rooflight panels set into the slope
  • the gutters, since HSE lists asbestos cement rainwater goods next to roof sheeting
  • white soffit boards under the eaves, which HSE's location list names as AIB, asbestos insulating board

You are shown the photographs. Where sheets are damaged, the survey says so plainly and sets out what has to be arranged before any repair begins. Our guide to fragile roofs and rooflights covers the wider picture for rooflight panels.

England and Wales: where the rules part

The fragility rule does not change at the border. HSE's guidance covers both countries, so an AC roof on a unit in Herefordshire and one on a unit in Monmouthshire are treated alike up on the roof. The differences come later, in the paperwork for waste, once sheets have been taken off. A roof in Powys or Monmouthshire follows the Welsh column below, and a roof in Herefordshire, Worcestershire, Gloucestershire or Shropshire follows the English one.

How asbestos waste is handled on each side of the border
PointEnglandWales
Consignment notesGOV.UK exempts domestic hazardous waste "other than asbestos waste"Contractors who move asbestos out of a home need consignment notes, NRW says
CarriersA carrier registers in the upper or lower tierA Welsh carrier registers with NRW, and a new upper tier entry costs £184

Roof waste from a business is business waste, so household routes do not apply to it. Herefordshire's recycling centre pages state that commercial or business waste is not accepted. The container rules are in our answer on asbestos sheets and skips.

When sheets are damaged or have to come off

HSE sorts asbestos cement work by what the job does to the material. Handling or lifting out sheets with care, so that they do not break, is non-licensed work, and HSE adds that this takes in weathered AC which has no other serious damage. Where sheets are already broken up or substantially damaged, or where lifting them would crumble them and raise significant dust and debris, the work moves into the notifiable non-licensed group. HSE's own example is "dropping" an asbestos cement roof.

A fragile roof keeps every job at the careful end of that line. Sheets cannot be thrown down or walked on, and a sheet that cracks mid-lift becomes a different category of job, so the removal plan is built around lifting whole sheets out from a platform and passing them to a lockable container. Who may do which kind of work is covered in our answer on removing asbestos cement sheets.

All of this belongs to our commercial roofing work. You receive the price in writing, as one total, once the survey has shown the condition of the sheets.

Related questions

Can I walk an asbestos cement roof if I keep to the purlin lines?

No. HSE's guidance makes no exception for staying over the supports, because it classes every AC roof as fragile. The route to the work is a platform or edge protection put in place before anyone goes near the roof, never a step onto a sheet, in England or in Wales.

Are the rooflights in an asbestos cement roof fragile too?

Treat them as fragile as well. A rooflight panel can be grimed over until it looks like the sheets beside it, and the sheets themselves are already classed as always fragile. Every panel on the roof is handled the same way until the survey has said otherwise.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing