01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Farm roofs

Farm building and barn roofs in Herefordshire: sheet types and asbestos cement

A barn roof can be old stone tile, corrugated asbestos cement or profiled metal, and the rules for each differ. This is how to tell them apart and what applies before anyone goes up.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Farm buildings across Herefordshire and the Welsh border counties carry roofs of every age. A stone-tiled barn can stand beside a Dutch barn clad in metal, and next to both sits a long shed roofed in corrugated sheets laid decades ago. The farmhouse and its outbuildings need not have been re-roofed together, so one holding can hold several roofing systems at once, each with its own failings and its own rules.

This post goes through the sheet types you will meet, and then the issues that set farm roofs apart from house roofs: asbestos cement, fragile sheeting, the disposal of old sheets, and the bats and birds that use the timbers. Rules that change at the border are tagged with the country they belong to. Roofs on farm buildings are commercial work, and our commercial roofing service covers them.

Nothing here is a substitute for a survey, which photographs the roof on the day and records what the sheets are.

The sheet types on a farm roof

Start by identifying the roofing material, because that decides the rest. Walk round the building and study the roof from the yard, with binoculars if you have a pair.

  • Stone tiles: heavy sandstone tilestones on the older barns. The building stone atlas on Herefordshire Council's site names the St Maughans beds as the chief supplier of tilestone here, and records permissions to work stone in the Golden Valley.
  • Clay or concrete tiles: a covering found on converted barns and farmhouse outbuildings.
  • Corrugated sheets: a wavy section in a grey, cement-coloured or painted finish. On older buildings these may be asbestos cement.
  • Profiled metal sheets: pressed steel or aluminium sheets with a deep, regular profile, seen on later sheds, sometimes with translucent panels set in.
  • Plastic or glass-fibre sheets: used as rooflights within the others.

You cannot tell asbestos cement from a cement-coloured sheet of another material by looking at it, and nobody should try to find out by scratching or drilling. HSE says: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." So an older shed is treated as holding asbestos until a test or a survey says otherwise.

Our guide to asbestos cement sheet roofs covers the sheet in more detail. On the farm, the point is that the survey begins with one question: what are the sheets? A lean-to on the side of the barn may be roofed differently from the barn itself, so each roof slope is checked on its own, with its own photograph. Rooflights are noted too, because they behave differently from the sheet around them.

Asbestos cement sheets: assume it and keep off the roof

HSE's guidance is short and firm on one point: "AC roofs are always fragile". Asbestos cement sheets can look sound and still give way under a person's weight, particularly where they are old and brittle. That makes an older sheeted roof two hazards at once: the fall through it, and the fibres released when it breaks.

For the owner, the sensible rules are plain:

  • Do not walk on a sheeted farm roof, and do not lean a ladder against the sheets.
  • Do not drill, scrub, cut or break the sheets.
  • Keep children, livestock and feed away from broken pieces and from the ground below a damaged sheet.
  • Do not pick up fallen pieces, sweep them or bury them.
  • Take pictures of the damage from a distance and wait for the survey.

A broken sheet lying in the yard is a bigger worry than a sound sheet overhead. Fibres are released when asbestos cement is broken, and a broken sheet left to weather gets worse. Mark the area off and keep animals away until it has been dealt with.

We do not take a sheet down on a guess. The survey notes the sheet type, photographs the roof from a safe vantage and records the condition of the sheets, the fixings and any rooflights before a method is chosen. If the sheets turn out to be something else, the job changes, and that is a better surprise than the reverse. The finding, whichever it is, goes into the quote.

Non-licensed, notifiable and licensed work

HSE sorts asbestos work into three groups, and the group depends on how the work is done as well as on the material. The table sets out what its pages say for asbestos cement and for insulating board.

HSE groups for asbestos work on roofs and rooflines
WorkHSE groupWhat HSE says
Taking asbestos cement sheets off with careNon-licensedRoof sheeting is covered "provided the material is carefully handled/removed without breaking up"
Sheets badly damaged or broken up, or a roof dropped in piecesNotifiable non-licensedCovers material "substantially damaged or broken up" and removal that would create "significant quantities of dust and debris"
Asbestos insulating board (AIB), as in white soffit panelsMostly licensedOnly short-duration work is notifiable non-licensed

The same page says weathered asbestos cement stays in the first group if it is not otherwise substantially damaged. Which side of the line a given roof falls on is a judgement made at the survey, and a broken roof moves into the notifiable group. A roof that seems fine from the yard may hide cracked sheets on the far slope, so the whole building is walked round before the method is fixed.

HSE's list of work that needs no licence sets the first group out in full. Insulating board is a different job, and when a roofline holds it we pass that part to a firm holding the licence. HSE's rules cover Great Britain, so the same groups apply in England and in Wales.

Taking old sheets away: skips, consignment notes and carriers

Old sheets cannot go in a standard skip. HSE says: "Use a lockable skip for asbestos", and "It is not good enough to throw sheeting over a standard skip". The instruction is a lockable skip, and an open one does not meet it.

The paperwork changes at the border:

  • In England, GOV.UK's exemption from consignment notes for domestic hazardous waste applies to waste "other than asbestos waste", and a farm building's waste is business waste in any case.
  • In Wales, Natural Resources Wales says: "contractors moving asbestos from a domestic property will need to use consignment notes." A carrier based in Wales has to register with NRW before it can move the waste, so ask to see the registration.
  • In England, GOV.UK has carriers register in an upper tier or a lower tier.

Council recycling centres are no help for a farm roof. Herefordshire Council's Hereford and Leominster centres accept household asbestos, double bagged, from the county's own residents, but "No commercial or business waste is accepted".

This is why the quote for a sheeted roof covers carrying and tipping as well as the stripping, and why anyone offering to take a roof away should say where it goes. Ask for the consignment details to be kept with the job file, and ask who is doing the carrying. Sheets leave the site in a lockable skip, and the yard is left clear of fragments. Gutters and downpipes in the same material are handled in the same way.

Bats, birds and the timbers under the sheets

Barns can hold bat roosts, and the law protects a roost even when the animals are away. Two separate rules apply. The Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 s9(4) treats disturbing a bat where it roosts, or shutting off the entrance it uses, as an offence only when done "intentionally or recklessly". Regulation 43 of the 2017 Habitats Regulations protects the roost itself, so spoiling a breeding site or a resting place is an offence whatever the person meant.

Licences come from different bodies:

  • In England, GOV.UK lists mending or renewing a roof among the activities that can disturb bats, and points to Natural England for a licence.
  • In Wales, Natural Resources Wales issues the licence, and NRW says one is needed for any work touching a protected species.

If droppings, staining or a bat turn up in the roof space, the work stops until a bat ecologist has advised. A barn roof job is planned round that possibility, not through it. Our answer on bats in barn roofs sets out the steps.

Birds are a separate matter. Under section 1 of the same Act a wild bird's nest is protected from being taken, damaged or destroyed, though the offence needs someone acting "intentionally" at a nest that is occupied or under construction. The survey checks for nests before the sheets are lifted, and an occupied nest stays untouched. The check is repeated whenever a new section of roof is opened up, and the pictures are kept with the job file.

Survey, access and how a barn roof is quoted

A farm roof is quoted after a survey, because there is no standard figure behind it. The reasons are practical. The sheets may need stripping or may be overclad. The building may be tall and wide, with the eaves hard to reach, and the ground round it is a working yard. On a farm business there are also things to arrange around the job: where stock and machinery go, and when.

What the survey records, in the order we go:

  1. The sheet type, from the ground and from a safe position.
  2. The condition of the sheets, the fixings and any rooflights.
  3. The purlins and rafters under the sheets, from inside.
  4. The gutters, the downpipes and the ground they discharge to.
  5. Signs of bats or nests.

On health and safety, the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 treat a person as a domestic client where the job is to their own home and has no link to a business. A barn used by a farm business is not that, so the client's duties stay with the client. Whatever the size of the job, a construction phase plan has to exist. Our guide to fragile roofs and rooflights goes through working practice on roofs that cannot bear weight.

One written total makes up the quote, with pictures of your own barn roof set beside the work it covers. The farm is left tidy, the old sheets are taken away, and the yard is checked for fragments before we leave.

Questions on farm roofs

Can I leave a broken asbestos cement sheet where it fell?

Leave it where it is, and keep people, livestock and feed away from it. Do not pick it up or sweep it. Asbestos cement releases fibres when it is broken, so the area needs to be marked off until the roof has been surveyed and the pieces have been dealt with.

Is removing an asbestos cement barn roof licensed work?

HSE puts the careful stripping of asbestos cement sheets, without breaking them, among the non-licensed jobs, on both sides of the border. A roof that is broken up in the process falls into the notifiable non-licensed group. Insulating board is a different case, because most work on it needs a licence.

Who licenses work on a bat roost in a barn?

In England bat work is licensed by Natural England; in Wales that falls to Natural Resources Wales. The Habitats Regulations make spoiling their breeding or resting places an offence whatever the intention, so a barn roof with signs of bats is looked at by a bat ecologist before the sheets are lifted.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing