01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Flat roof choice

EPDM, GRP or felt? Choosing a flat roof for a Hereford extension or garage

Three systems cover most flat roofs on extensions and garages. Each has its own lifespan range, its own way of being laid, and the same need for a fall and for insulation.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Over an extension or a garage, a flat roof covers little ground yet carries a large share of the argument. Three systems cover the choice for a house roof: EPDM, GRP and felt. Each forms a waterproof skin on top of a deck, and each can leak at an edge or an upstand, so the skin is only half of what you are buying. The other half is the fall that clears water, the insulation under it, and the detail where it meets the house.

This post compares the three on points with published figures: how long each is reported to last, what a fall is and what the standard asks for, what warm deck means, where the insulation rules part ways between England and Wales, and what a garage roof costs on national figures. It does not rank the three, because the right choice is decided by the particular roof.

It sits under our flat roofing service, where the work is described in full.

The three systems in plain terms

The names are shorthand, so it helps to say what each one is before comparing them.

  • EPDM: a single sheet of synthetic rubber, rolled out over the deck and bonded or fixed down, with the joins and edges sealed by hand. It can be called rubber roofing.
  • GRP: glass-reinforced plastic, built up on site from resin and glass fibre laid wet over the deck, which sets into a single hard skin. It is also called fibreglass.
  • Felt: layers of bitumen-coated membrane, laid by torch or bonded with adhesive and built up in more than one layer over the deck. The torch-on kind is the form the cost guides price.

An EPDM sheet is rolled out in one piece, a GRP skin is laid wet into the shape of the roof, and felt goes on in lapped widths, so the places to check at an edge or a join differ from one system to the next. At a survey those places are checked by torch and photographed, and the pictures go to you.

None of that decides the choice. The deck underneath, the edges, the way the water leaves and the insulation all matter at least as much as the skin on top. We look at those first, and photograph them, and then the covering is chosen to fit the roof and not the other way round. A roof that is sound underneath can take any of the three; a roof with a rotten deck needs the deck dealt with before any of them.

How long each is reported to last

Lifespan is the point owners want settled, and two published sources give different ranges for each system. Both are shown here, because they disagree, and neither can be read as a guarantee for any one roof.

Reported lifespans from two named sources
SystemHomeBuildingLess
EPDM25-30 years30 to 50 years
GRP25-30 years25 to 40 years
Torch-on felt10-15 years10 to 20 years, depending on quality and installation

HomeBuilding's table was last updated on 30 September 2025, and the Less page was updated on 27 October 2026. The gap between the sources is itself a lesson: a range is a range, and where a roof falls inside it depends on the installation, on the deck and on whether the edges and outlets are kept clear and sound.

Read across the rows and felt is the shortest-lived of the three on both sets of figures, while EPDM and GRP overlap. That is a reading of the sources, not a ranking of the products, and it does not tell you which one suits your extension. Our short answers on how long EPDM, GRP and felt last give the same figures one system at a time.

A lifespan range also says nothing about the years before the first fault, and a roof can need repair work well inside its range. Edges, outlets and the abutment against the main house are worth inspecting at intervals whatever the covering.

Falls: the water has to leave the roof

A roof called flat still slopes. The slope is a fall, too gentle to see from the garden, and its job is to carry rain off the roof. Water that stands is a question of the fall before it is a question of the covering.

BS 6229:2025 is the present standard where a flat roof has a flexible, continuously supported waterproof covering, which takes in felt and EPDM membranes. It does not cover lead sheet, and for a GRP roof the question to ask at the survey is what fall that system is laid to. The earlier edition, BS 6229:2018, was withdrawn on 16 December 2025.

  • NFRC reads the 2025 standard as a minimum 1:80 finished fall, for main roof areas and internal gutters alike. In plain terms that is 12.5 mm of drop for each metre of run.
  • That is a finished fall, the slope of the roof as it is left.
  • IKO advises designing for 1:40 to end up with 1:80. Do not read 1:80 as a design figure; it is the floor for the finished roof.

Gutters follow a separate rule of thumb: Brett Martin gives "1mm for every 600mm" for a rainwater gutter. A roof edge that drains into a gutter has two falls to get right, one for the deck and one for the gutter.

Our guide to flat roof falls and drainage shows how a fall is set out on site, and how ponding on an old roof is read.

Warm deck and the insulation rules on each side

A warm deck roof has its insulation laid above the structural deck, under the waterproof skin, so the deck sits on the inside of the insulation. A cold deck puts the insulation between or below the joists, with the deck outside it. The choice shapes the build-up, the ventilation and the edge details, and it applies to all three coverings. Our guide to warm deck or cold deck sets out the difference in more detail.

The insulation rules differ by country:

  • In England, AD L 2021 lists a renewed waterproofing layer among its renovation work. Table 4.3 gives a roof threshold of 0.35 and an improved figure of 0.16. Paragraph 4.13 relaxes that where 0.16 would not pay back within 15 years, with an upgraded element generally not exceeding 0.7.
  • In England, AD L 2021 Table 4.2 sets 0.15 for a roof element newly built into an existing house.
  • In Wales, the Welsh Government says that when a roof with integral insulation is renewed, upgrading the thermal element may be required.
  • In Wales, Welsh AD L Table 11.1 gives 0.16 for a renovated flat roof, not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible, and Table 4.1 gives 0.13 where a new roof is fitted to an existing house.

Ask building control, in either country, how an extension roof is treated, because the answer depends on how the extension is built.

These tables hold until the next editions arrive: AD L 2026 from 24 March 2027 in England, and a new Welsh AD L from 4 March 2027.

Garage roofs and what the national figures say

A plain garage roof, with no valleys and few upstands, is where the national cost figures tell you the most. They are dated, they are national, and they are not ours.

  • Which? (November 2025 survey, excluding VAT): felt on a flat roof over a single garage of typical size, 6m by 3m, "£1,400-£3,500"; other materials such as PVC or rubber EPDM with new boards, "£1,950-£4,000".
  • MyJobQuote (page dated 26 October 2026): the 2026 average garage roof replacement is put at £750 to £3,500.
  • MyJobQuote (page dated 20 October 2026): the average flat roof replacement in 2026 is put at £1,500 to £6,000, with felt at £80 to £120 per m² installed.
  • MyJobQuote (page dated 9 October 2026): rubber roofing averages around £1,050.

Per-square-metre rates stay per-square-metre rates. Checkatrade's repair rates of June 2026 (excluding VAT, per m², up to 3 m²) are £120 to £170 for EPDM and £130 to £180 for GRP, and they describe repairs, not a new roof. For GRP, the price comes once the roof has been surveyed.

If the garage roof is corrugated sheet and the building dates, by build or refurbishment, from before 2000, HSE advises that it must be presumed to hold asbestos, and nobody should break or drill the sheets. MyJobQuote puts asbestos roof removal at around £2,750, and a 20 m² garage roof at around £1,200 for survey and removal. Our guide to garage roof replacement in Hereford covers that case, and the farm roofs post covers the sheet types.

Choosing without a winner

There is no best system for every flat roof, and a page that names one is guessing. What the survey looks at decides the shortlist:

  1. The deck: its condition, its material and whether it is already falling the right way.
  2. The outline: long and plain, or full of corners, upstands and rooflights.
  3. The edges: where the flat roof meets the main house, the gutter and any parapet.
  4. The insulation: what sits under the old covering, and which rule applies in England or Wales.
  5. The access: whether the roof can be reached safely, and whether scaffold is needed.

With those answers, the three systems begin to separate. A long, plain run with few details points one way. A small, awkward roof with penetrations points another. A roof where lifespan matters more than outlay points a third. In each case the covering is matched to how the roof was built, and to whichever national rules cover the property.

You receive a single written total after the survey, and the photographs of your roof show that the work priced matches what is up there. The old covering goes off site and the area is left clear, with the outlets and gutters checked before we go.

If you are weighing a patch against a full replacement, our guide to patching or replacing a flat roof covers that decision first, and the roof survey will tell you which side of it you are on.

Questions on choosing a flat roof

Do HomeBuilding and Less agree on how long EPDM lasts?

No. HomeBuilding gives 25-30 years and Less gives 30 to 50 years. These are typical ranges, not commitments. How long a particular roof lasts depends on the installation, the deck, the fall and whether the edges and outlets are kept clear and sound over the years.

What fall does a finished flat roof need under BS 6229:2025?

NFRC reads the standard as a minimum 1:80 finished fall. IKO's advice is to design for 1:40, to end up with 1:80. The 1:80 is the lowest acceptable fall on the completed roof and not a design figure, and it is for felt and EPDM membranes.

Does renewing the covering on a flat roof trigger insulation rules?

It can. In England, AD L 2021 includes renewing a flat roof membrane in its list of renovation work, so Table 4.3 applies. In Wales, the Welsh Government says renewing a roof with integral insulation may require the thermal element to be upgraded. Ask building control which applies.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing