In brief
In England, up to three bodies can be involved. The Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Areas Act 1979, in section 2, makes damaging a scheduled monument, or tipping on its land, an offence unless the works are authorised, and consent is given by the Secretary of State. A listed cross is a matter for the council under section 7 of the 1990 Act, unless it is in an exempt church's curtilage and so shares its exemption. A Church of England roof in use goes through the faculty system.
Three protections, three decision makers
A cross in a churchyard may carry one protection, two or none, and the first step is to establish which, since that settles where the application is sent. Churchyard crosses are among the oldest structures in many parishes, and a cross may be a base and a shaft, a stump or a rebuilt head, so its protection is not obvious from the lane.
| What it is | Consent | Decided by |
|---|---|---|
| Scheduled monument | Scheduled monument consent | The Secretary of State |
| Listed structure outside an exempt church's curtilage | Listed building consent | The council |
| Parish church in Church of England use, with listed structures in its curtilage | Faculty | The diocese's faculty system |
The list entry for a cross, if it has one, states the grade and the address. The council can tell you whether a structure in a churchyard is listed, scheduled or neither, and a cross may have been moved or rebuilt, which can matter for its record. The church's own status does not tell you the cross's status, so ask about each separately, and ask whether the churchyard wall, gate or lychgate has a listing of its own, since those can be missed. Write down the answers.
What the 1979 Act covers
Section 2 of the 1979 Act, on scheduled monuments, makes it an offence to carry out, cause or allow certain works to a scheduled monument unless they are authorised. The works it names are:
- anything that demolishes, destroys or damages the monument
- works to remove or repair it, or to alter or add to it
- flooding or tipping operations on land with a scheduled monument in, on or under it
Authority arrives as the Secretary of State's written consent, and the works must follow what it allows, together with whatever conditions it sets. The section also provides defences, which our guide to scheduled monuments and roof work sets out in full.
For a roofer, the third item is the one to watch. A skip, a stack of stripped slates or a heap of spoil from a scaffold base placed on a scheduled monument's land could amount to tipping, and the section does not ask whether the tipping was meant to harm. We therefore plan where materials go with as much care as we plan the repair itself.
Scaffold, skips and ladders near a cross
Roof work on a church may not touch a cross directly, but the work around it can, and a cross that stands only a few paces from the wall is easy to catch with a ladder or a swinging load. The risk sits in the margins: where the scaffold stands, where a ladder rests, where waste is piled and how a hoist is swung. A cross near the nave wall, a porch or a lychgate is exactly where the scaffold plan needs thought.
Before a church roof job we:
- walk the ground with the churchwarden or owner and mark out the cross and any other monument
- agree where the scaffold feet go, clear of the base, the steps and any kerb that surrounds it
- agree a storage and skip position well away from the cross
- photograph the ground and the cross before anything is erected, then again when the scaffold comes down
If poles must go on the public road, section 169 of the Highways Act 1980 applies, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. The scaffold position, the skip and the licence are all settled before anyone climbs the tower or the nave.
The church roof itself
The roof of a Church of England church in daily use is not a council matter, which surprises some parishioners. The Ecclesiastical Exemption (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) (England) Order 2010 keeps the exemption for church buildings within the faculty jurisdiction of the Church of England, so the work goes through the diocese's faculty system, which has its own forms and timetable. Our guide to church roofs, faculties and exemptions sets out the other exempt bodies.
A scheduled cross is separate. It needs scheduled monument consent in its own right, and that consent is not part of any faculty. DCMS notes that no faith or denomination outside the order's list benefits from the exemption, so a chapel outside that list goes to the council for listed building consent.
Our listed and heritage roofing page explains how we survey a church roof, from the ridge down, and what the photographs are used for. Our quote is one total in writing and covers the whole job, and you can ask it to say how the scaffold and VAT are treated.
