In brief
A timber-framed roof moves because the structure under it is a set of joined timbers, not a solid wall. Oak shrinks across the grain as it dries, pegged joints loosen over the years, and the frame rests on a stone base that can settle. The covering has to follow. On a listed house, repairs that alter the frame or the covering need consent, under the 1990 Act in England and the 2023 Act in Wales.
What a frame does that a masonry wall does not
The Herefordshire building stone atlas explains how local frames stand. The bottom beam, the sole-plate, can lie on a sandstone or siltstone plinth, and everything above it, walls and roof, rises from that line. Every joint in the frame is cut and pegged, and each timber carries load through its fit.
Four things make a frame shift:
- Drying. Oak shrinks across the grain as it dries, which opens joints.
- Seasonal change. Timber takes up and gives off moisture through the year, so the frame flexes a little with the weather.
- Settlement. The plinth beneath can sink or shift, and the frame follows it.
- Past alterations. A beam cut away for a chimney or a doorway shifts load onto timbers never framed to take it.
A frame that has moved is not necessarily a frame in trouble. An old house can have settled into its present shape long ago and stayed in it since, with only small seasonal changes. What matters is whether the movement is still going on, and the survey looks for exactly that: fresh gaps, bright timber where a joint has opened, and dust below a beam.
How movement shows up on the roof
The roof is where a frame's movement becomes visible from the lane. A ridge that dips, a verge that bows and a gable that leans away from the line of the slope each deserve a closer look. So do slates or tiles that have slipped along a single line, since a rafter that has settled takes its covering with it, and the pieces above the line can lose their grip.
On a timber-framed house we look at the skyline first and then follow any movement downward. We check and photograph:
- the ridge line against the sky, for dips or kinks
- the gable ends, where the frame meets the covering
- the chimney stack and its flashings, where stone and oak move at different rates
- slipped, cracked or lifted coverings that sit on one line
The stack deserves its own mention. The atlas observes that these houses' big outside stacks can be built of local sandstone. Stone does not flex the way the frame beside it does, so a rigid fixing at the junction between the two can crack.
Repairs that allow for a frame that flexes
A repair on a frame that moves should be able to move with it. A rigid bed of mortar along a ridge, or a hard flashing chased into a stack, can crack as the frame shifts. A lead flashing with soakers, or a ridge held by mechanical fixings as well as mortar, can allow for a little movement. Marley says that installing to BS 5534 "isn't required by law", but it also says mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering".
| Detail | Rigid choice | Frame-friendly choice |
|---|---|---|
| Ridge | Mortar alone | Mortar with mechanical fixings |
| Stack junction | Hard mortar fillet | Lead flashing and soakers |
| Gable end | Cemented verge | Verge detailed to suit the frame |
None of this removes the need to ask. On a listed house a new fixing method still alters how the roof looks and works, and the council decides whether that touches its character. Our guide to roofs on black-and-white houses covers the details house by house.
Consent, wildlife and the frame
Work that touches a listed frame needs consent first. In England, section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 applies to works that would change a listed building's special character. In Wales, section 88 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 asks that such works are authorised through section 89. The council holds the answer for your building.
Old frames shelter wildlife too. Section 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 treats a nest in use or being built as protected, so anyone who intentionally harms one commits an offence. Bats and the places they rest are protected as well, with licences coming from Natural England for English addresses and from Natural Resources Wales for Welsh ones, and the survey notes droppings and staining at the eaves.
A survey on a timber-framed roof therefore looks for both before any timber is disturbed. Our guide to bats in old buildings sets out the licences, and our listed and heritage roofing page explains the survey. What we quote afterwards is one figure on paper.
