Anyone planning roof work on an English parish church meets the same surprise: the council's listed building consent, the route for a listed house, is not the route here. The Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 carves out church buildings that are in use for worship, and a separate system takes over. For the Church of England that system is the faculty, a permission that comes through the diocese.
It sounds simple until the roof is considered. A church roof carries lead gutters, a slate or stone covering, a tower parapet and a chancel that may be older than the nave. Each of those is part of a building that is listed, at Grade I, II* or II, and each may bring in a different decision-maker if something about the building or its use falls outside the exemption.
This guide sets out what the exemption covers in England, who is inside it, where it stops, and what we do on a church roof before any consent question is settled. It belongs to our listed and heritage roofing work. Houses are different: for them, consent does run through the council.
What the exemption actually says
The rule is in section 60 of the 1990 Act. The listed building controls "shall not apply to any ecclesiastical building which is for the time being used for ecclesiastical purposes". Two phrases carry the weight. The word ecclesiastical narrows it to church buildings, and the phrase for the time being used ties it to use today, not to what the building was built as. A listed church that has closed loses the exemption while it stands empty, and a listed building that is not a church never had it.
The detail of which denominations qualify comes from the Ecclesiastical Exemption (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) (England) Order 2010. Article 5 of that Order says: "The ecclesiastical exemption is retained for church buildings within the faculty jurisdiction of the Church of England." Article 7 does the same for four other denominations, which the next section lists.
The exemption does not mean a church is unregulated. The controls it replaces are listed building consent and conservation area control, and a church system takes their place. The roofer follows whatever specification that system approves, which means asking before any estimate is turned into a start date.
One limit is worth stating early: the exemption applies to the building and its use together. A parish church in regular use is plainly inside it. A closed church is a different case, and the fourth section below covers it.
Who is inside the England list
Article 5 names the Church of England. Article 7 of the 2010 Order, read with its Schedule, names four more groups. The explanatory note puts it in one sentence: Article 7 "retains the exemption for church buildings of the Roman Catholic Church, the Methodist Church, the Baptist Union of Great Britain and the United Reformed Church". The wording of the Order is available on legislation.gov.uk.
| Body | Route for works to a church in use |
|---|---|
| Church of England | Faculty, within the diocese's faculty jurisdiction |
| Roman Catholic Church | Its own denominational system |
| Methodist Church | Its own denominational system |
| Baptist Union of Great Britain | Exempt where a Schedule 1 trust corporation holds the building, outside any diocese |
| United Reformed Church | Its own denominational system |
The Baptist entry is worded carefully. The Order refers to a church that belongs to the Baptist Union of Great Britain, with its buildings held by a trust corporation named in the Schedule. A Baptist church does not answer to a diocese, so the word faculty has no place in a Baptist conversation, and the trust corporation holding the building is the thing to ask about.
A faculty, a Roman Catholic diocesan process, a Methodist process and a United Reformed process are four different things. If you manage a building in one of these groups, check with its governing body about the route before the roof is touched, and ask what that body needs from a roofer. A parish church, a Catholic church and a Methodist chapel may all stand within sight of each other in a market town, and each answers to a different body.
How a faculty fits round a roof job
A faculty is the permission that the Church of England's own jurisdiction gives for changes to a church building. Because the application sits inside the church system, the council is not the decision-maker for the roof, and listed building consent is not what the building needs. The work goes through the diocese's faculty system, and the church can find out from its governing body what the diocese wants to see.
What a roofer can contribute is evidence. A faculty request for roof work is stronger when it is built on a record of the roof as it is, and a record of what is proposed. At the survey we produce:
- photographs of each slope, valley, gutter, parapet and flashing, with the defects marked
- a description of the existing covering and how it is fixed
- the proposed repair or renewal, stated in materials and methods, including lead codes where leadwork is involved
- the price, written as a single total for the work as described
The church or its architect decides how that material is used. We do not say who files the paper or when it will be decided, because those are matters for the diocese and the church. We do say plainly if the proposal goes beyond like-for-like, because a change of material is the kind of change that draws questions.
Timing needs a word. Work cannot start under a faculty until it has been granted, and waits vary, so we do not promise a start date. A temporary make-safe, such as a tarpaulin over a failed valley, is a separate matter, and it is worth asking the church's governing body how it wants that handled.
Where the exemption stops
Several common situations fall outside it, and in each the ordinary secular controls apply:
- Other faiths and denominations: the Department for Culture, Media and Sport's guidance says: "No other faiths or denominations currently benefit from the Ecclesiastical Exemption". A listed Unitarian, Quaker or other chapel therefore needs listed building consent.
- Churches Conservation Trust buildings: the same guidance says "Secular controls also cover buildings vested in the Churches Conservation Trust".
- Closed and redundant churches: once a church no longer has an ecclesiastical use, section 60's "for the time being used" test fails. Our short answer on redundant church roof consent goes through this case.
Scheduled monuments are a separate matter again. Section 2 of the 1979 Act on ancient monuments makes works to a scheduled monument an offence "unless the works are authorised", and the consent comes from the Secretary of State. A churchyard cross, a ruined chapel or an earthwork in the grounds can be scheduled even when the church beside it is exempt. Our guide to scheduled monuments and roof work covers where that line falls.
It also helps to know that the exemption relates to listed building and conservation area controls only. It leaves other regimes where they were, which the next section covers.
When it is unclear which side of the line a building sits on, we ask the owner for three facts before the survey: the denomination, whether worship still takes place, and the listing details if there are any. With those three, the route can be clear before anyone climbs a ladder, and a roof that falls outside the exemption can be priced with the council consent in mind.
What the exemption does not cover: Building Regulations and scaffold
Exemption from listed building consent does not switch off the rest. For a heavier new covering, AD A para 4.4 treats a roof loading that is "increased by more than 15%" as a significant change, so a church that wants slate in place of a lighter covering, or a lead replacement in a thicker code, has a structural question to answer. Whether the work needs Building Regulations approval is a matter for the council's building control or a registered building control approver, and we ask before the job is booked, because a structural answer costs far less to get before the covering is ordered than after it is on site.
Wildlife law also stays in place. A church roof can shelter bats and nesting birds, and our guide to bats in old buildings sets out the offences and the licensing bodies.
Scaffold is a real cost on a church because the building is tall and the repair may take weeks. Herefordshire Council sets its fee at £167 where the licence runs for a maximum of 1 month, adds £123 for each further month, and wants at least 10 days' notice. We arrange the licence with our scaffolder. These are the council's own figures for its own highway and do not apply to other councils.
The quote should say whether scaffold and VAT sit inside the total. Our quote is a single total given after the survey, so a church committee can set it beside whatever paperwork its own governing body requires.
Roof coverings, lead and stone on an English parish church
Herefordshire's village churches show the range of coverings the county uses. Pembridge's church of St Mary stands at Grade I on the National Heritage List (entry 1081754), and the 1934 Herefordshire inventory describes stone slates and slates on that parish church. Weobley's parish church is Grade I (entry 1301343), and the same inventory notes stone slates alongside ordinary slates on its roofs. Those are historic descriptions from 1934, not a count of what any roof is made of today.
Stone roofs in the county use tilestones of local sandstone, with the St Maughans sandstones named in the stone atlas as the principal source. SPAB adds that such roofs "are predominantly double-lapped", and that "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries".
Church leadwork asks for heavier codes than a house. In the Royston Lead table, codes 5 and 6 are listed for flashings as well as parapet and box gutters, while codes 7 and 8 are listed for those gutters but not for flashings. BS 6229 deals with membranes only, and AD C names BS 6915 for lead. On lifespan, HomeBuilding gives a lead flat roof "60-100 years", and Less gives "50 to 100 years". Lifespans like these are typical ranges, not promises.
Our survey records the covering, the fixings, the lead and the state of the timbers beneath, so the repair can be matched to what the church has. A church roof can combine several of these materials on different slopes and in different centuries, so the specification names each one separately instead of treating the roof as a single surface, and the photographs show the reader where each begins and ends.
